Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Monday, October 4, 2010

The Cost of Anything is Everything

Money was the first universal standard of value. While even today there is not yet a universal unit of money, the art of trading the coins of different nations at some fair exchange rate is well recorded in some of mankind's earliest documents.

Economics got its modern thrust largely from Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, published in 1776, and still probably the best single book on econmics ever written. Carl Marx shocked the political and economic world with his mid-18th century Labor Theory of Value in which he noted that all productive economic activity involved human labor. If one allowed that all human time spent in productive work was of roughly equal value (or took into account qualitative differences in individual efforts, and used the average as a standard hour of labor), one could see that anything from a bushel of corn to a railway locomotive could be seen to have embodied in it some number of hours of human labor.

The labor theory of value is interesting, but has had limited use. More recently there have been numerous descriptions of how economic activity can be measured in terms other than money. One of the most commonly cited lately is energy. How much energy is used to cool a house, grow a head of lettuce, serve up a Facebook page? Popular press articles act as if these quantities are simple to calculate. But they are not.

Taking one example, measuring the energy required to cool one house on one hot summer day seems easy enough. You just put a meter on the outlet leading to the air conditioner. But what about the cost of the air conditioner? Why, its money cost should be depreciated over the life of the machine, and the energy costs of producing the machine accounted for in a similar manner. And what of the house itself? Should we depreciate the insulation? The roof? The cost of the foundation, or the power lines, or the road to the house?

I say, why bother with all that. If energy really is the secret currency of our time, it should show up more or less accurately in all pricing. The price of something corresponds pretty well to the energy that went into the something. A Prius actually wastes a lot more energy than a Ford Focus, because the initial price shows how much more energy was needed to produce the Prius. Better gas economy over the lifetime of the car won't compensate for the intial energy cost differential.

The cost of air conditioning in dollars, and depreciating the cost of the air conditioner itself, captures energy units used almost as well as more detailed systems.

There are many items besides energy that go into everything. Research and development expense is an interesting universal. Look around you: everything has been improved by research and development. Gas motors and electric motors, the bread from the wheat produced by scientific farming, the special machines of bread baking factories. Even when inventions are ancient, like paper making, smelting metal, and cloth production, R&D has been at work making improvements in what we actually use or how it is produced. Generally speaking, modern goods are created with less labor and more capital investment, thus upending much of the thinking that went into the labor theory of value.

The almost total interconnectedness of almost all things used by today's humans has become the fundamental reality of this era. Almost anything can be used to measure the cost of all other things, if you want to. Tantalum metal for capacitors, which are used in communications and information processing, which are used in all production and distribution of goods. Corn itself, which is used to grow new human beings as well as food animals. Nitrogen-based fertiliser, without which everything, and I mean everything, would collapse in two years. Water. Coffee. Antibiotics. Plastic. Education. Even Law, medical services, or accounting.

In this column I mainly write about individual technology companies and their prospects for future growth. We have seen in the recent global economic downturn how financial prospects are interwoven, and how good people and companies can be hurt when bad practices (predatory lending and credit bubbles, for instance) undermine the rest of the production system.

It would do well to keep in mind that the cost of anything is everything. If I buy a new car (I am at that point), it seems to be a discrete thing, bought in a discrete transaction. But any new car contains parts made by hundreds of companies. The employees who make the car and its parts consume goods made by hundreds of companies. The engineers who designed the car based their efforts on hundreds of years of earlier science, technology and engineering. The option of buying a car would not be available to me if it were not for a complex global network of people and things.

The system of production also produces negative side effects that society is slow to deal with. Air and water polution, crime of many sorts, even war. Everything we buy, and every service we consume, could be measured in terms of these negative valuations as well.

The cost of anything, of any particular thing, is everything. That is just the nature of society. We can make individual adjustments to the mix. That is what humans do when we make the choices in our lives.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Virtuous Economic Cycle Components

After a severe recession there are going to be some very damaged sectors of an economy. They don't all spring back at once. Some lead, some lag the general upturn. While past upturns offer patterns that may be repeated, the economy is a complex beast, so it is not surprising if details differ in each cycle.



In 2009 the stock market indexes hit bottom, then had a good climb. In 2010 so far we have been up and down a number of times, ending around flat today after a good start to September. Not knowing history, one might theorize that the stock market should have a damping effect on economic cycles (not dipping as deeply, not rising as quickly). This would be because a common theory is that stocks are about future value. So stock prices should take into account long-term returns, which should in turn take into account the cycles of growth and recession that characterize capitalist economies.


But, in just one for-instance, in early 2009 the stock market averages dipped far more, as a percentage, than GDP. Same in the 2001 crash. But in 2001 the fall came mainly because leading up to 2000 investors forgot to take into account that the profitability of the companies' would drop when a recession took hold. The Federal Reserve failed in its duty to dampen a bubble because big egos mistakenly believed, and told the mass of investors, that cycles were over, to be replaced by more-or-less steady economic growth.


At its bottom in 2009 the stock market was suffering from the opposite delusion: that the economy would never recover. I would argue that in 2007, with the exception of the banking sector, most stocks had in fact priced in the entire economic cycle. The commodity sector had not, and of course housing prices and loans against housing had not. Many people lost all or much of their retirement investments not because they had invested badly, but because they panicked and sold near the bottom.


The big price swings in stocks are because they are auction markets. They are efficient at matching buyers with sellers, but they overprice and underprice securities when there is a deficit of one party or the other.


Today housing, both used housing stock and the building of new housing, is still weak. There are still some pockets of vacuum where people pretend there are loans that will be repaid; there is still turbulence. But the economy can suffer a fair amount of turbulence without crashing.


Demand continues to pick up despite the fact that we are no longer seeing net stimulus from the government sector. Some sectors of the economy are showing strength, notably agriculture and export-oriented industry. Those who are employed are much more confident of keeping their jobs than they were a year ago. They also, on the whole, have paid down their debts and are in a much better position to shop more without getting themselves into trouble. So I would expect that as the employed spend more retailers will be encouraged to do more hiring.


That is the thing about the virtuous part of the cycle. More hiring means more retail sales, and less of a drain on government for unemployment compensation and the like. More retail sales means more manufacturing. And in turn more hiring.


In 2011 we can expect people who have huddled together in houses and apartments to save money to begin to feel secure enough to venture out on their own. That means more rental income (if not increased rents or housing prices, at first) and, after all these many years, the absorption of excess housing stock.


All these processes take time. The stock market is an important part of this cycle. People spend more when their stocks are up. Those who own stocks represent a disproportionate part of the spending equation. If investors are so cautious that stocks take another dive, that will slow down the natural upswing. If the market moves up smartly in the near term, that will accelerate the recovery.

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

The Oil Price Oscillator

Most Americans have noticed gasoline prices have been jacked up for the summer driving season. Those who read the financial pages know there is a glut of oil and gasoline available. If the corporations that set pricing keep prices up, and demand remains low, the glut will still be there in September.

But if there is an economic recovery, either in the U.S. or globally, the current glut will work down to normal levels and then to shortages. Prices will get jacked up further at the pump. And that, in turn, should moderate any economic upswing. It might even bring consumer consumption of everything but gasoline crashing back down.

It is very possible that we are in a period of oil prices being the primary oscillator for the economy. That is, when oil prices are up, the economy will slow, stall, and then decline. Oil prices will then fall by a greater percentage than the economy as a whole. Which only allows the economy to repeat the cycle.

This is a limits-to-growth scenario. It assumes the economy can only grow so much without more oil as an input, because the price of oil determines how much of the economic pie is left for everything else.

Over time, oil prices should become less of a controlling factor. We have already seen some of this. The shift from low mile-per-gallon SUVs to smaller cars and hybrids is just one example of how the shift could take place in the long run.

Some economists and analysts will get out their spread sheets and try to make numeric predictions about exactly how oil and gasoline prices will affect the economy in the short run. When dealing with something as complex as the economy, using a rule of thumb is more honest than pretending you can predict with finer granularity. There are too many other factors affecting the macroeconomy, ranging from how the Federal Reserve sets interest rates to billions of one time decisions by individuals that are small in themselves but in aggregate create macroeconomic trends.

Friday, July 11, 2008

Cash is King

The United States of America has a long history of booms financed largely by credit followed by periods of recession and limited credit. You don't have to be an economist to see these trends. You do have to be a calculating, unemotional investor to take advantage of them. Take the Kennedy family. They were doing pretty well during the 1920's, but Joseph Kennedy knew his history and economics. He cashed out well before the crash. Then, in the depth of the Depression, he went on a buying spree with the cash he had. Thus a family of little economic note went from the lower middle class to being one of the richest in America in a single generation. Only then did the political experience of the family, previously of account only in Boston, bloom into a dynasty of national importance.

There is nothing wrong with taking credit under appropriate circumstances. Between 1936 and 2003 buying a house on credit was a sound investment in most of the United States. Taking some credit to ease a business startup can be rewarding too. But even when these general rules applied, there were specific counterexamples. Buying a house in a city whose factories moved to Mexico or China, or even to Alabama, did not work out for a lot of people. Most small businesses fail or limp along.

You would think with the Internet stock bubble of the late 1990's in the rear view mirror that people would have been more cautious about buying McMansions on credit between 2002 and 2006. In the vast majority of cases, while the price of the house was an issue, the two main factors in the personal disasters were buying a house that was too big, and spending too much on luxuries (often fueled by additional loans).

For about a year and a half now we have been seeing the other side of the equation, a contraction of credit. The Federal Reserve was created to minimize the credit cycle, but it did a poor job at that starting when Alan Greenspan took over. Voodoo economics, the theory that markets always reach an equilibrium that has good results for humans, can only partly be blamed. Credit was created off the Federal Reserve's books, so to speak, and like Enron stockholders, the Fed acted like that was none of its business.

In 1928 Al Smith was the Democratic Party candidate for President. Herbert Hoover won by a landslide; he was already a national hero. The Dixie wing of the Democratic Party could not get the voters behind Smith, a Catholic whose only real political difference with Herbert Hoover was that he was for ending Prohibition (of the sale of alcohol). If Al Smith had won the election there would still have been a Great Depression. The Republican Party would have come to power in 1932, and as the credit cycle turned it would have established itself again as the party of Prosperity. History would be very different.

While we are in a credit crunch, cash is king. Unless you want to use your dollars to buy foreign assets, you can buy almost any investment cheap. Stocks, bonds, real estate, you name it.

True, if the U.S. or world economy collapses, you will look like a fool for not holding onto your cash. But if that happens, all bets are off; even cash may not save you. A collapse is not very likely. Parts of our economy, notably agriculture and manufacturing not related to construction, are doing quite well. Unless the Fed or Congress does something really stupid, there will be a bottom and then a liftoff period. No one will really be able to see the bottom until it is a quarter or two behind us.

Best bet in this environment? Stocks and bonds of well-established, profitable companies with global distribution networks. Buy what looks cheapest on a value basis; don't read too much into other people's selling, which is based on their liquidity needs and their fears. Figure this credit squeeze will last a while, which means spreading your conversion of cash into assets over time. Keep in mind that the important bottom is the credit bottom, not the stock market bottom.

And keep diversified.

Monday, June 25, 2007

Housing Market Distortions

Most traditionalist economists believe that markets are always in equilibrium. I believe that markets are almost always out of equilibrium. The questions speculators have to answer correctly are: how much, and in which direction.

Comparing the housing market and the stock market can give a lot of insight into causes of disequilibrium. The stock market can be broken down into stocks that are heavily traded and stocks that are thinly traded. To a large extent the national housing market behaves like a heavily traded stock, but local markets trade more like thinly traded stocks.

Another useful dichotomy: is the trading auction style, or swap style? By swap style I mean the traditional markets as described by Adam Smith: a rational (or at least savvy) person at each end, trading something of value, when there is an elastic supply of the two items (one usually being money) to be traded.

Today there is an almost 10 month supply of unsold houses on the U.S. national market. Two years ago houses more often than not sold the day they were put on the market; houses under construction sold before construction began. Yet the economy is arguably stronger on the whole today that it was two years ago. Anyone who argues that the housing market, or sale prices of housing, is always at equilibrium is saying nothing. They are defining equilibrium to be whatever happens. Same for stock prices.

Suppose you are going to buy something; it could be a stock or a house. As long as the price is rising and continuing to rise it makes sense to buy as soon as possible. Maybe normally you would save up a 20% down to get a good interest rate on a mortgage; but with prices increasing, it makes more economic sense to put 5% down and pay a higher interest rate now, rather than waiting two (or ten) years to save up the down.

The same becomes true when prices are falling. Why buy house now, even if you want it and think it will be a good long term investment, if you think you can buy it for 5% or 10% less if you just wait 6 months?

Rising prices accelerate demand, which in turn makes prices rise more. That is one reason why stock prices and housing prices tend to be out of equilibrium. Falling prices tend to dampen immediate demand, which in turn causes prices to fall more. That is the other main reason prices are usually out of equilibrium. These tendencies are the basis of macroeconomic cycles and of stock market price fluctuations that may last hours, weeks or even years (or, with super-fast computerized program trades, fractions of a second).

Auction systems aggravate these trends, partly because of human psychology and partly because they create a short-term artificial scarcity or surplus. Price swings in thinly traded, illiquid stocks display this.

Buyers in the housing market aren't going to be in a hurry until prices start rising again. The exact turning point won't be obvious, partly because it will take place in different localities at different times. The willingness, and ability, of lenders to finance purchases may stall or accelerate the process of finding a bottom.

But there will be a bottom. Strangely, the longer it takes to reach it, and the deeper the retreat in prices is, the more people will think there is no bottom.