now at Seeking Alpha:
Nvidia's Competitive Outlook
While Nvidia is actually one of my favorite companies from way back, I have not owned the stock for years. Partly that is due to my shifting my earlier mostly IT technology portfolio to one that has become more than half biotechnology. You can also see notes on last-week's Nvidia Second Quarter 2013 analyst call (Q2 fiscal 2014)
Next up is Applied Materials. Marvell Technologies reports on Thursday, so I am likely to write about that on Friday.
Showing posts with label nvda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nvda. Show all posts
Tuesday, August 20, 2013
Monday, December 5, 2011
NVIDIA Takes Up ARMs
Back in February I warned that "at $25.48 [per share], you might want to consider that it could take NVIDIA [NVDA] a couple of years of outstanding growth to justify this price."
Maybe it is just the stock market and macroeconomic turmoil, but NVDA closed today at $15.48.
What I think about the pricing of a stock is only loosely linked to what I think of a company. As to engineering and execution, I have long believed NVIDIA is one of the best technology companies in the world. As the long-term leader in computer graphics chips (GPUs), however, it is now at a crossroads where the old rules no longer seem to apply. It is a time of both tremendous opportunity and tremendous danger, which makes predicting future profit streams mainly guesswork.
NVIDIA reported fiscal Q3 results and held its analyst conference call on November 10, 2011. Note the quarter ended October 30, so its not a calendar quarter and chips going into consumer products for the holidays pretty much had to be out the door by the end of the quarter. Q4, ending January 30th, is historically a slower quarter for NVIDIA. Note also that rivals AMD and Intel had quarters ending September 30.
Revenues were $1.07 billion, up 5% sequentially from $1.02 billion and up 26% from $840 million in the year-earlier quarter. Net income was $178.3 million, up 18% sequentially from $151.6 million and up 110% from $84.9 million year-earlier. EPS (earnings per share) were $0.29, up 16% sequentially from $0.25 and up 93% from $0.15 year-earlier.
That is pretty strong growth over the past year. However, from a licensing deal and litigation settlement with Intel, NVIDIA got roughly $60 million in royalties it did not get a year earlier (the royalties run about another 5 years). That had some impact on revenue and a huge impact on net income and EPS. It is real money, but it did not come from chips sales.
At this point NVIDIA has two games going. One is in its classic discrete GPU chips, which are now also used as math and application acceleration co-processors. Its only real rival in that market is AMD.
The other is combining its graphics engine with ARM chip designs for mobile devices. That results in a chip called Tegra. The first version was interesting but did not generate much revenue. Tegra II sold a lot better, and has powered a number of smartphones and tablets. Tegra III, or Kal-El, became available in the quarter, so a few devices are available now and it will be widely available in 2012. NVIDIA management did not break out Tegra revenue for the quarter.
The NVIDIA vision is not just to dominate the smart phone and tablet markets. Future versions of Tegra are supposed to be powerful enough to go into notebooks, desktops, and even servers.
The problem with being in the ARM market is that anyone can license the ARM design. Graphics and cell phone connectivity chips and designs are available as well. NVIDIA seems tight with Google, but any ARM-based design can run the Android software.
Competitors each have some advantages. Apple, of course, is the perceived frontrunner. There is no guarantee that the iPhone is ultimately going to be defeated by Android-based phones or less likely competitors.
When it comes to ARM based chips for tablets and phones, each competitor brings some serious advantages to the court. Qualcomm has far more extensive experience in cell phone chips than NVIDIA does; so does Texas Instruments. Among a host of other contenders, Marvell (MRVL) should be noted, since they generate a lot of cash each quarter and have a lead in China, a much bigger market to fight over than the U.S. market. Then there are the Koreans, and Japanese, and numerous small innovators.
Another problem for NVIDIA is the lack of a x86 CPU chip design. AMD and Intel both are incorporating graphics into their base designs, eliminating the need for NVIDIA's GPU chips for most users. This already appears to be hurting them in the notebook segment. It will take some time and at least a couple of die shrinks before the pure GPU chip dies (except in specialty markets), but that time is coming at a fairly predictable clip.
So far profit margins have been good at the leading edge of smartphone and tablet processors, but at some point pricing could become more competitive.
2012 is likely to be a make or break year for NVIDIA. If they are able to dominate the Android phone market they might become the dominant semiconductor company, a position Intel has had for a couple of decades now. Myself, I am not willing to make that bet, but I'll keep a close watch. However, I do believe NVIDIA's price is now pretty reasonable, everything taken into account.
See also my Q3 NVIDIA analyst call summary.
Disclaimer: I have no position in NVIDIA and will not take a position for at least 2 weeks following the publication date of this article.
Keep Diversified!
Maybe it is just the stock market and macroeconomic turmoil, but NVDA closed today at $15.48.
What I think about the pricing of a stock is only loosely linked to what I think of a company. As to engineering and execution, I have long believed NVIDIA is one of the best technology companies in the world. As the long-term leader in computer graphics chips (GPUs), however, it is now at a crossroads where the old rules no longer seem to apply. It is a time of both tremendous opportunity and tremendous danger, which makes predicting future profit streams mainly guesswork.
NVIDIA reported fiscal Q3 results and held its analyst conference call on November 10, 2011. Note the quarter ended October 30, so its not a calendar quarter and chips going into consumer products for the holidays pretty much had to be out the door by the end of the quarter. Q4, ending January 30th, is historically a slower quarter for NVIDIA. Note also that rivals AMD and Intel had quarters ending September 30.
Revenues were $1.07 billion, up 5% sequentially from $1.02 billion and up 26% from $840 million in the year-earlier quarter. Net income was $178.3 million, up 18% sequentially from $151.6 million and up 110% from $84.9 million year-earlier. EPS (earnings per share) were $0.29, up 16% sequentially from $0.25 and up 93% from $0.15 year-earlier.
That is pretty strong growth over the past year. However, from a licensing deal and litigation settlement with Intel, NVIDIA got roughly $60 million in royalties it did not get a year earlier (the royalties run about another 5 years). That had some impact on revenue and a huge impact on net income and EPS. It is real money, but it did not come from chips sales.
At this point NVIDIA has two games going. One is in its classic discrete GPU chips, which are now also used as math and application acceleration co-processors. Its only real rival in that market is AMD.
The other is combining its graphics engine with ARM chip designs for mobile devices. That results in a chip called Tegra. The first version was interesting but did not generate much revenue. Tegra II sold a lot better, and has powered a number of smartphones and tablets. Tegra III, or Kal-El, became available in the quarter, so a few devices are available now and it will be widely available in 2012. NVIDIA management did not break out Tegra revenue for the quarter.
The NVIDIA vision is not just to dominate the smart phone and tablet markets. Future versions of Tegra are supposed to be powerful enough to go into notebooks, desktops, and even servers.
The problem with being in the ARM market is that anyone can license the ARM design. Graphics and cell phone connectivity chips and designs are available as well. NVIDIA seems tight with Google, but any ARM-based design can run the Android software.
Competitors each have some advantages. Apple, of course, is the perceived frontrunner. There is no guarantee that the iPhone is ultimately going to be defeated by Android-based phones or less likely competitors.
When it comes to ARM based chips for tablets and phones, each competitor brings some serious advantages to the court. Qualcomm has far more extensive experience in cell phone chips than NVIDIA does; so does Texas Instruments. Among a host of other contenders, Marvell (MRVL) should be noted, since they generate a lot of cash each quarter and have a lead in China, a much bigger market to fight over than the U.S. market. Then there are the Koreans, and Japanese, and numerous small innovators.
Another problem for NVIDIA is the lack of a x86 CPU chip design. AMD and Intel both are incorporating graphics into their base designs, eliminating the need for NVIDIA's GPU chips for most users. This already appears to be hurting them in the notebook segment. It will take some time and at least a couple of die shrinks before the pure GPU chip dies (except in specialty markets), but that time is coming at a fairly predictable clip.
So far profit margins have been good at the leading edge of smartphone and tablet processors, but at some point pricing could become more competitive.
2012 is likely to be a make or break year for NVIDIA. If they are able to dominate the Android phone market they might become the dominant semiconductor company, a position Intel has had for a couple of decades now. Myself, I am not willing to make that bet, but I'll keep a close watch. However, I do believe NVIDIA's price is now pretty reasonable, everything taken into account.
See also my Q3 NVIDIA analyst call summary.
Disclaimer: I have no position in NVIDIA and will not take a position for at least 2 weeks following the publication date of this article.
Keep Diversified!
Saturday, May 14, 2011
NVIDIA Explains Smartphone and GPU Strategies
The NVIDIA (NVDA) analyst call on Thursday was characterized by a relatively short presentation and long question and answer session. Analysts pressed a variety of concerns while management explained their view of the technology space and their strategy for increasing revenue and profits. [See also call details at Nvidia Q1 fiscal 2012 analyst call news summary.]
The explaining was necessary because revenues were $962.0 million, up 8.5% sequentially from $886.4 million, but down 4% from $1.002 billion in the year-earlier quarter. GAAP net income was $135.2 million, down 21% sequentially from $171.7 million, and down 2% from $137.6 million year-earlier. GAAP EPS (earnings per share) were $0.22, down 24% sequentially from $0.29, and down 4% from $0.23 year-earlier. Those numbers include a $40 million payment from Intel for intellectual property (really, to keep NVIDIA a strong ally against AMD); take that out, and the y/y comparisons look worse, while Q1 last year was nothing to shout about either.
So what are the issues? NVIDIA is exiting the motherboard chip set business, which originally became necessary because of a dispute with Intel. AMD has cut heavily into NVIDIA's former dominance in the discrete GPU (graphics) chip and card business. NVIDIA's supercomputer graphics business actually shrank a bit, though management argued it would expand down the road.
That leaves the savior of the moment, Tegra, a chip that runs cell phones and tablets. The newest one is Tegra 2, which everyone admits is a big improvement over the original Tegra. Tegra chips generated $122 million in the quarter, which is a lot of money, until you compare it with losses from the humble chip set business, or the bulk of NVIDIA's revenue, or smartphone chip revenue of some competitors.
NVIDIA claims they are going to take market share in the discrete graphics chips for notebook computers segment. Their only real competitor, AMD, says the same thing. But the good thing about discrete GPU chip competition is there are just those two players. The competition between them is intense, but at least it is somewhat predictable.
In smartphones and tablet computers, however, almost everyone is licensing the core processor design from ARM and adding graphics, Wi-Fi, and cellular modems as best they can. The competition is multifold. Qualcomm was the pack leader two years ago, and still outsells NVIDIA heavily. TI is very competive and believes it now is closer to the heart of Google (maker of the Android smartphone operating system) than NVIDIA, 2010's sweetheart. Apple makes its own ARM based processor for the iPhone and iPad. If they all disappeared there would be Marvell, which dominates the hard drive chip sector and has slots in a number of phones, including the new OPhones in China. There are other players in Korea, Japan, and China. Then there are the non-ARM entries, mainly for tablets but eventually for smartphones, from AMD and Intel.
And anyone can license the intellectual property to make a smartphone chip. In other words, there could be more players in 2012, not less.
Which is too many players. Consolidation will take place, probaby around 2013 when smartphones have completed replacing the bulk of not-so-smart cell phones. While the competition so far has been on technology, with points for speed, usability, and low-power consumption, at some point price will become an important issue. Profit margins will be squeezed.
I certainly believe NVIDIA is as competitive as any of the other companies I named. But there are going to be losers. There will have to be losers. It is next to impossible to predict who they will be.
Given that, investors might want to think about going lower down the food chain, to the companies that make semiconductor manufacturing equipment like Applied Materials or printed circuit boards for smartphones like TTM Technologies.
Of the companies named above, I currently own stock in Applied Materials, TTM Technologies, Marvell, and AMD. In the past I owned stock in NVIDIA.
See also NVIDIA
Keep diversified!
The explaining was necessary because revenues were $962.0 million, up 8.5% sequentially from $886.4 million, but down 4% from $1.002 billion in the year-earlier quarter. GAAP net income was $135.2 million, down 21% sequentially from $171.7 million, and down 2% from $137.6 million year-earlier. GAAP EPS (earnings per share) were $0.22, down 24% sequentially from $0.29, and down 4% from $0.23 year-earlier. Those numbers include a $40 million payment from Intel for intellectual property (really, to keep NVIDIA a strong ally against AMD); take that out, and the y/y comparisons look worse, while Q1 last year was nothing to shout about either.
So what are the issues? NVIDIA is exiting the motherboard chip set business, which originally became necessary because of a dispute with Intel. AMD has cut heavily into NVIDIA's former dominance in the discrete GPU (graphics) chip and card business. NVIDIA's supercomputer graphics business actually shrank a bit, though management argued it would expand down the road.
That leaves the savior of the moment, Tegra, a chip that runs cell phones and tablets. The newest one is Tegra 2, which everyone admits is a big improvement over the original Tegra. Tegra chips generated $122 million in the quarter, which is a lot of money, until you compare it with losses from the humble chip set business, or the bulk of NVIDIA's revenue, or smartphone chip revenue of some competitors.
NVIDIA claims they are going to take market share in the discrete graphics chips for notebook computers segment. Their only real competitor, AMD, says the same thing. But the good thing about discrete GPU chip competition is there are just those two players. The competition between them is intense, but at least it is somewhat predictable.
In smartphones and tablet computers, however, almost everyone is licensing the core processor design from ARM and adding graphics, Wi-Fi, and cellular modems as best they can. The competition is multifold. Qualcomm was the pack leader two years ago, and still outsells NVIDIA heavily. TI is very competive and believes it now is closer to the heart of Google (maker of the Android smartphone operating system) than NVIDIA, 2010's sweetheart. Apple makes its own ARM based processor for the iPhone and iPad. If they all disappeared there would be Marvell, which dominates the hard drive chip sector and has slots in a number of phones, including the new OPhones in China. There are other players in Korea, Japan, and China. Then there are the non-ARM entries, mainly for tablets but eventually for smartphones, from AMD and Intel.
And anyone can license the intellectual property to make a smartphone chip. In other words, there could be more players in 2012, not less.
Which is too many players. Consolidation will take place, probaby around 2013 when smartphones have completed replacing the bulk of not-so-smart cell phones. While the competition so far has been on technology, with points for speed, usability, and low-power consumption, at some point price will become an important issue. Profit margins will be squeezed.
I certainly believe NVIDIA is as competitive as any of the other companies I named. But there are going to be losers. There will have to be losers. It is next to impossible to predict who they will be.
Given that, investors might want to think about going lower down the food chain, to the companies that make semiconductor manufacturing equipment like Applied Materials or printed circuit boards for smartphones like TTM Technologies.
Of the companies named above, I currently own stock in Applied Materials, TTM Technologies, Marvell, and AMD. In the past I owned stock in NVIDIA.
See also NVIDIA
Keep diversified!
Labels:
Android,
Apple,
arm processors,
cell phones,
gpu,
graphics,
nvda,
nvidia,
oPhone,
Qualcomm,
smartphones,
tablet computers,
tegra,
TTM Technologies
Thursday, February 17, 2011
NVIDIA Price Counts on Tegra Ramp
(original title: NVIDIA: Counting Chickens Before They Hatch)
As an analyst and investor, one of the main things I do is count chickens before they hatch. Today graphics chip specialist NVIDIA has a high price-to-earnings ratio (non-GAAP 62x trailing, 26x leading), indicating some investors are counting on a lot more chicken profits in the future than they have been seeing lately. Is this a smart assumption?
NVIDIA will have a profit boost for the next six years from its licensing deal with Intel. For the most recent quarter ending January 30, 2011 it booked $57 million for the litigation settlement portion of the deal (booked as a negative operating expense, not revenue). For each quarter it will book about $60 million in royalties.
Other than that, the last couple of years have been hard on NVIDIA. Q4 fiscal 2011 (the most recently reported quarter) revenues were $886.4 million, down 10% from $982.5 million in the year-earlier quarter. That does not sound like a high-growth company that deserves high PEs on its stock price. [for a fuller report on Q4, see NVIDIA Q4 fiscal 2011 analyst conference call summary]
What speculators are speculating on is a chip called Tegra. The first version was interesting but did not generate much revenue. The second version is available now in a few tablet and smart phone devices. It produced little revenue in Q4, but is supposed to contribute substantially to Q1. Therefore, instead of a normally seasonally down Q1, guidance is for a 6% to 8% sequential revenue ramp. That is impressive, if it happens.
In addition, the third version of Tegra, called Kal-El for now, is already sampling and is supposed to be in devices for sale for holiday 2011 shopping. Reviews of Tegra 2 are generally positive.
The NVIDIA vision is not just to dominate the smart phone and tablet markets. Future versions of Tegra are supposed to be powerful enough to go into notebooks, desktops, and ever servers.
Before you pay a premium for all them chickens, you might want to think about all the other chickens that will be on the market. NVIDIA's Tegra CPU unit is based on the ARM architecture, which anyone can license. The NVDA advantage is in graphics, but there are a number of companies that license graphics capabilities that were designed specifically to work with ARM. NVIDIA's were designed to work with the 8086 architecture of Intel and AMD.
Competitors each have some advantages. Apple, of course, is the perceived frontrunner. There is no guarantee that the iPhone is ultimately going to be defeated by Android-based phones or less likely competitors.
When it comes to ARM based chips for tablets and phones, each competitor brings some serious advantages to the court. Qualcomm has far more extensive experience in cell phones than NVIDIA does; so does TI. Intel and AMD want to get into the game. AMD gained a lot of market share against NVIDIA in discrete graphics cards for computers during 2009 and 2010; their fusion chips offer some extreme advantages, especially for tablet computing. Among a host of other contenders, Marvell (MRVL) should be noted, since they generate a lot of cash each quarter and have a lead in China, a much bigger market to fight over than the U.S. market. Then there are the Koreans, and Japanese, and numerous small innovators.
None of the other contenders have PE ratios as high as NVIDIA's. I have owned NVIDIA stock in the past, and if it had a low PE I might scoop up those chickens right now. I have always admired NVIDIA's technological skills, and the Tegra 3 is promissing. I don't see how it can be all that much better than competitors, however. Everyone has promissing designs, everyone is hustling to squeeze usability out of the same limitations of silicon.
I have done well recently with some hatchlings at Dot Hill, Dendreon, and TTM. On the other hand, I like to keep in mind Anesiva, where I correctly predicted its Zingo product would hatch (get FDA approval), only to watch it die a horrible death and then take the entire company into bankruptcy with it. The secret is to see them chickens before momentum investors drive up the stock prices. If you bought NVDA a year ago at $8.65 per share, congratulations. If you are thinking about buying it today at $25.48, you might want to consider that it could take NVIDIA a couple of years of outstanding growth to justify this price.
As an analyst and investor, one of the main things I do is count chickens before they hatch. Today graphics chip specialist NVIDIA has a high price-to-earnings ratio (non-GAAP 62x trailing, 26x leading), indicating some investors are counting on a lot more chicken profits in the future than they have been seeing lately. Is this a smart assumption?
NVIDIA will have a profit boost for the next six years from its licensing deal with Intel. For the most recent quarter ending January 30, 2011 it booked $57 million for the litigation settlement portion of the deal (booked as a negative operating expense, not revenue). For each quarter it will book about $60 million in royalties.
Other than that, the last couple of years have been hard on NVIDIA. Q4 fiscal 2011 (the most recently reported quarter) revenues were $886.4 million, down 10% from $982.5 million in the year-earlier quarter. That does not sound like a high-growth company that deserves high PEs on its stock price. [for a fuller report on Q4, see NVIDIA Q4 fiscal 2011 analyst conference call summary]
What speculators are speculating on is a chip called Tegra. The first version was interesting but did not generate much revenue. The second version is available now in a few tablet and smart phone devices. It produced little revenue in Q4, but is supposed to contribute substantially to Q1. Therefore, instead of a normally seasonally down Q1, guidance is for a 6% to 8% sequential revenue ramp. That is impressive, if it happens.
In addition, the third version of Tegra, called Kal-El for now, is already sampling and is supposed to be in devices for sale for holiday 2011 shopping. Reviews of Tegra 2 are generally positive.
The NVIDIA vision is not just to dominate the smart phone and tablet markets. Future versions of Tegra are supposed to be powerful enough to go into notebooks, desktops, and ever servers.
Before you pay a premium for all them chickens, you might want to think about all the other chickens that will be on the market. NVIDIA's Tegra CPU unit is based on the ARM architecture, which anyone can license. The NVDA advantage is in graphics, but there are a number of companies that license graphics capabilities that were designed specifically to work with ARM. NVIDIA's were designed to work with the 8086 architecture of Intel and AMD.
Competitors each have some advantages. Apple, of course, is the perceived frontrunner. There is no guarantee that the iPhone is ultimately going to be defeated by Android-based phones or less likely competitors.
When it comes to ARM based chips for tablets and phones, each competitor brings some serious advantages to the court. Qualcomm has far more extensive experience in cell phones than NVIDIA does; so does TI. Intel and AMD want to get into the game. AMD gained a lot of market share against NVIDIA in discrete graphics cards for computers during 2009 and 2010; their fusion chips offer some extreme advantages, especially for tablet computing. Among a host of other contenders, Marvell (MRVL) should be noted, since they generate a lot of cash each quarter and have a lead in China, a much bigger market to fight over than the U.S. market. Then there are the Koreans, and Japanese, and numerous small innovators.
None of the other contenders have PE ratios as high as NVIDIA's. I have owned NVIDIA stock in the past, and if it had a low PE I might scoop up those chickens right now. I have always admired NVIDIA's technological skills, and the Tegra 3 is promissing. I don't see how it can be all that much better than competitors, however. Everyone has promissing designs, everyone is hustling to squeeze usability out of the same limitations of silicon.
I have done well recently with some hatchlings at Dot Hill, Dendreon, and TTM. On the other hand, I like to keep in mind Anesiva, where I correctly predicted its Zingo product would hatch (get FDA approval), only to watch it die a horrible death and then take the entire company into bankruptcy with it. The secret is to see them chickens before momentum investors drive up the stock prices. If you bought NVDA a year ago at $8.65 per share, congratulations. If you are thinking about buying it today at $25.48, you might want to consider that it could take NVIDIA a couple of years of outstanding growth to justify this price.
Labels:
amd,
Apple,
cell phones,
competition,
graphics,
intel,
Kal-El,
Marvell,
nvda,
nvidia,
P/E ratio,
Qualcomm,
revenues,
smart phones,
tablet computers,
tegra
Monday, November 29, 2010
NVIDA Hopes for Tegra processors
Graphics chip maker NVIDIA (NVDA) has had its ups and downs these past few years, and not just because of the recession. Increased competition from AMD in the discrete graphics card market has hurt. So has the accelerating loss of its "chip set" (chips for integrating a cpu to other components) business. At the very high end NVIDIA is getting traction for its Tesla computational chips, but those revenues are not likely to make up for other losses. It is possible NVIDIA will do better in its competition with AMD in 2011, but it is telling financial analysts that Tegra chips for mobile devices are its next big thing.
At its November 11, 2010 analyst conference call and report on its third quarter (Q3, ending October 31, 2010), Tegra was touted as a replacement for lost chip set revenue and more. Note revenue were down 7% y/y to $843.9 million in a period when most semiconductor companies ramped revenues by double digits.
Note also that Tegra has been around for a number of years. What we have been promised in 2010 is a new, improved Tegra, with an improved software stack make the new devices using it something device makers feel can compete with the iPad. This has resulted in a least a half-year delay in releasing product; the products are largely a 2011 story. Management believes that touch-based systems are going to wipe out older systems, and that Tegra will make NVIDIA a serious player in the field.
Maybe, but I am not the only analyst who is a bit skeptical, and with good reason. Tegra 2 might be improved enough to be a revolutionary epicenter in 2011, but it might get lost in the forest of competing platforms. Essentially Tegra combines an ARM CPU with a GeForce GPU, in much the same way that AMD's Fusion chips combine an 8086-based CPU with a Radeon GPU. ARM is a low-power architecture that is being widely used to address the mobile device market.
The problem for NVIDIA is that lots of companies are selling ARM-based processors for mobile devices. Apple designed its own. NVIDIA's advantage would be its graphics technology, but it is not yet clear how much of an advantage they really have. Many companies are using graphics chips, or integrating graphics architecture onto a chip, that was designed, like ARM, to be low-power from the ground up.
The history of Tegra is not one of blazing success. Microsoft Zune and KIN were flops. Maybe the 2011 devices will be better than Apple, but will they sell? They won't be competing with just iPads and iPhones, but with a wide variety of devices. Note too that some of NVIDIA's competitors have huge advantages in the mobile market derived by expertise in areas like Wi-Fi and cell phone modem chips.
For device makers there are a number of competing strategies to choose from. Do you want to start with the best graphics, or perhaps the best cell phone 4G technology? Or if devices become largely indistinguishable, maybe the low price supplier is the key to success.
I have owned NVIDIA stock in the past, but right now I think there are better bargains to be had. If Tegra ramps as rapidly as management would like, then sure, today's stock price looks nice. But I believe this is a wait and see situation. The new Tegra devices may come on the market as early as Q1 2011, but I want to see how they sell through. One popular device could make Tegra viable again, but only Apple seems to be able to guarantee the popularity of its own devices. Once you step outside of Apple, what I mostly see is ruinous competition.
See also:
My NVIDIA analyst call summary for Q3 2010
http://www.nvidia.com/
At its November 11, 2010 analyst conference call and report on its third quarter (Q3, ending October 31, 2010), Tegra was touted as a replacement for lost chip set revenue and more. Note revenue were down 7% y/y to $843.9 million in a period when most semiconductor companies ramped revenues by double digits.
Note also that Tegra has been around for a number of years. What we have been promised in 2010 is a new, improved Tegra, with an improved software stack make the new devices using it something device makers feel can compete with the iPad. This has resulted in a least a half-year delay in releasing product; the products are largely a 2011 story. Management believes that touch-based systems are going to wipe out older systems, and that Tegra will make NVIDIA a serious player in the field.
Maybe, but I am not the only analyst who is a bit skeptical, and with good reason. Tegra 2 might be improved enough to be a revolutionary epicenter in 2011, but it might get lost in the forest of competing platforms. Essentially Tegra combines an ARM CPU with a GeForce GPU, in much the same way that AMD's Fusion chips combine an 8086-based CPU with a Radeon GPU. ARM is a low-power architecture that is being widely used to address the mobile device market.
The problem for NVIDIA is that lots of companies are selling ARM-based processors for mobile devices. Apple designed its own. NVIDIA's advantage would be its graphics technology, but it is not yet clear how much of an advantage they really have. Many companies are using graphics chips, or integrating graphics architecture onto a chip, that was designed, like ARM, to be low-power from the ground up.
The history of Tegra is not one of blazing success. Microsoft Zune and KIN were flops. Maybe the 2011 devices will be better than Apple, but will they sell? They won't be competing with just iPads and iPhones, but with a wide variety of devices. Note too that some of NVIDIA's competitors have huge advantages in the mobile market derived by expertise in areas like Wi-Fi and cell phone modem chips.
For device makers there are a number of competing strategies to choose from. Do you want to start with the best graphics, or perhaps the best cell phone 4G technology? Or if devices become largely indistinguishable, maybe the low price supplier is the key to success.
I have owned NVIDIA stock in the past, but right now I think there are better bargains to be had. If Tegra ramps as rapidly as management would like, then sure, today's stock price looks nice. But I believe this is a wait and see situation. The new Tegra devices may come on the market as early as Q1 2011, but I want to see how they sell through. One popular device could make Tegra viable again, but only Apple seems to be able to guarantee the popularity of its own devices. Once you step outside of Apple, what I mostly see is ruinous competition.
See also:
My NVIDIA analyst call summary for Q3 2010
http://www.nvidia.com/
Thursday, November 11, 2010
Cisco Leads Market Lower After Conference
The market is being led lower by Cisco (CSCO) today. Yesterday Cisco released slightly disappointing results and, at its analyst conference call, gave very disappointing guidance for the current quarter, which is Cisco's Q2 fiscal 2011.
In short, government spending is a big part of Cisco's pie, and government spending, especially by American states that have balanced-budget provisions, was weak. A second area of weakness was sales of set top boxes to cable companies.
For a more detailed report try my Cisco fiscal Q1 2011 analyst conference call summary.
I don't own Cisco stock.
Up today is NVIDIA. But I have other conferences to cover for clients, so I may not be posting my NVDA conference call summary (Q3 fiscal 2011) until late tonight or even Friday. But you can bookmark the page and return to it later.
For a complete list of technology stocks I cover for the public, see analyst conference call list.
In short, government spending is a big part of Cisco's pie, and government spending, especially by American states that have balanced-budget provisions, was weak. A second area of weakness was sales of set top boxes to cable companies.
For a more detailed report try my Cisco fiscal Q1 2011 analyst conference call summary.
I don't own Cisco stock.
Up today is NVIDIA. But I have other conferences to cover for clients, so I may not be posting my NVDA conference call summary (Q3 fiscal 2011) until late tonight or even Friday. But you can bookmark the page and return to it later.
For a complete list of technology stocks I cover for the public, see analyst conference call list.
Labels:
analyst conferences,
Cisco,
CSCO,
nvda,
nvidia,
technology
Monday, August 16, 2010
NVIDIA (NVDA) Risks, Opportunities
Last Thursday, August 12, 2010, NVIDIA (NVDA) reported its results for the quarter ending August 1, 2010, its second fiscal quarter of 2011. The results could be taken as a glimpse into July for the semiconductor industry since most other companies in the space reported second quarters ending June 30th. There is a concern that the recent boom in chip sales could slow appreciably because of slowing (but not really reduced) end demand by businesses and consumers.
Here I want to discuss the big trends engulfing Nvidia and the future of computer processing, including graphics processing. If you are interested in details of Nvidia's 2nd quarter, see my NVIDIA Q2 Analyst Conference Call summary.
Since graphics on personal computers began to be important in the late 1980s there has been a divergence between the central processing unit (CPU) and the graphics processing unit (GPU). Fans of history may recall that before that there was a similar divergence between the CPU and the floating point processor (FPU); you could pay extra for a computer with an Intel 8087, if you wanted to do math, or use math to accelerate graphics calculations.
This divergence between general computing needs and floating point math and graphics needs is fundamental. In an era that may be coming to a close Intel and AMD (and once upon a time, Motorola) produced most of the CPUs for the industry while ATI (now part of AMD) and Nvidia made the graphics processing unit. Many computers had no GPU, allowing the graphics work to be done by the CPU, which is fine for slow work like word processing. Intel, Nvidia and AMD also all made motherboard chipsets that included some GPU capabilities. As usual, those became more capable with time. Your $1000 GPU card of 2000 is not as powerful as the lowest end Intel graphics of today. On the other hand graphics demand has gone up with both the introduction of high definition video, fast rendering needs of games, and graphic content production systems. You don't want Intel graphics for any of those.
Conversely, the powerful GPUs from Nvidia and AMD can now be used to accelerate many processes that CPUs do more slowly. Mostly scientists, engineers, and graphics designers are taking advantage of these capabilities, but they will trickle down towards the mainstream. Moms may use them to convert an HD video to lower definition, or vice-versa.
For the most part FPUs were killed when floating point processing started being integrated into CPUs like Intel's Pentium. As transistor sizes shrank, and Windows became the common operating system, that became a natural way to give users more for their dollar.
2010 is the year that GPUs and CPUs are being merged onto a single chip. Unless you are an industry insider, you won't see the products until 2011.
Because high end GPUs actually use more silicon space than the current CPUs, there will continue to be life for independent GPUs, typically on video cards, for at least a few years. Video and graphics content makers, scientists and engineers will want workstations that include both a high end GPU and a high end CPU card. But the rest of us will probably migrate to the new combined cards (AMD calls them APUs, advanced processing units) between 2011 and 2015.
While Intel might be behind AMD in graphics, I would not want to bet on its losing a lot of market share in the new combined CPU/GPU arena. Intel's profits dwarf AMD's revenues, and their R&D budget is correspondingly higher. They will find ways of keeping their market share, most likely.
For Nvidia there is a bigger problem: they don't make GPUs at all. But before addressing that, let's look at the new tide coming in: mobile processing, mostly based on ARM-based processors.
Mobile devices are rapidly becoming more powerful, as you can see from the iPad, iPhone, Droid, etc. The key is low voltages with corresponding low power consumption, plus the usual shrinking of transistor sizes making it possible to integrate more processing capabilities into the processing units.
It is conceivable that just as PCs wiped out minicomputers and even, for the most part, mainframes, the new mobile CPUs could start invading the notebook, desktop, and even server computer space. It is already being tried, the reasoning being that a swarm of small, low-energy units can make ideal virtual machines for serving web pages.
Nvidia has the Tegra platform, which you'll be seeing a lot of later this year. It integrates an ARM CPU, an Nvidia GPU, and motherboard chipset functions on a single chip. It is a beautiful piece of work.
It also appears to be winning out over AMD in the high end GPU for non-graphic computations market.
I am not ready to declare the long line of evolution from 8086 chips to be over. They may just absorb what is best, and morph to meet changing user needs. But the competitive dynamics are certainly going to change in the next few years. If Nvidia's Tegra is a competitor, so are chips from Apple, Marvell, Broadcom, Qualcomm, TI, and many others. In fact too many companies have pinned their hopes on ARM processors. Even if ARM becomes the architecture of the future, it is likely that a couple of these companies will gain a marketing or manufacturing advantage, and the field will narrow over time.
Nvidia's best hopes for future profits are probably in specialized graphics processors for high-intensity computing. These may no longer be necessary for the average person's desktop or notebook, but high-end GPUs are subject to much less competition and therefore have higher profit margins on each unit sold.
Here I want to discuss the big trends engulfing Nvidia and the future of computer processing, including graphics processing. If you are interested in details of Nvidia's 2nd quarter, see my NVIDIA Q2 Analyst Conference Call summary.
Since graphics on personal computers began to be important in the late 1980s there has been a divergence between the central processing unit (CPU) and the graphics processing unit (GPU). Fans of history may recall that before that there was a similar divergence between the CPU and the floating point processor (FPU); you could pay extra for a computer with an Intel 8087, if you wanted to do math, or use math to accelerate graphics calculations.
This divergence between general computing needs and floating point math and graphics needs is fundamental. In an era that may be coming to a close Intel and AMD (and once upon a time, Motorola) produced most of the CPUs for the industry while ATI (now part of AMD) and Nvidia made the graphics processing unit. Many computers had no GPU, allowing the graphics work to be done by the CPU, which is fine for slow work like word processing. Intel, Nvidia and AMD also all made motherboard chipsets that included some GPU capabilities. As usual, those became more capable with time. Your $1000 GPU card of 2000 is not as powerful as the lowest end Intel graphics of today. On the other hand graphics demand has gone up with both the introduction of high definition video, fast rendering needs of games, and graphic content production systems. You don't want Intel graphics for any of those.
Conversely, the powerful GPUs from Nvidia and AMD can now be used to accelerate many processes that CPUs do more slowly. Mostly scientists, engineers, and graphics designers are taking advantage of these capabilities, but they will trickle down towards the mainstream. Moms may use them to convert an HD video to lower definition, or vice-versa.
For the most part FPUs were killed when floating point processing started being integrated into CPUs like Intel's Pentium. As transistor sizes shrank, and Windows became the common operating system, that became a natural way to give users more for their dollar.
2010 is the year that GPUs and CPUs are being merged onto a single chip. Unless you are an industry insider, you won't see the products until 2011.
Because high end GPUs actually use more silicon space than the current CPUs, there will continue to be life for independent GPUs, typically on video cards, for at least a few years. Video and graphics content makers, scientists and engineers will want workstations that include both a high end GPU and a high end CPU card. But the rest of us will probably migrate to the new combined cards (AMD calls them APUs, advanced processing units) between 2011 and 2015.
While Intel might be behind AMD in graphics, I would not want to bet on its losing a lot of market share in the new combined CPU/GPU arena. Intel's profits dwarf AMD's revenues, and their R&D budget is correspondingly higher. They will find ways of keeping their market share, most likely.
For Nvidia there is a bigger problem: they don't make GPUs at all. But before addressing that, let's look at the new tide coming in: mobile processing, mostly based on ARM-based processors.
Mobile devices are rapidly becoming more powerful, as you can see from the iPad, iPhone, Droid, etc. The key is low voltages with corresponding low power consumption, plus the usual shrinking of transistor sizes making it possible to integrate more processing capabilities into the processing units.
It is conceivable that just as PCs wiped out minicomputers and even, for the most part, mainframes, the new mobile CPUs could start invading the notebook, desktop, and even server computer space. It is already being tried, the reasoning being that a swarm of small, low-energy units can make ideal virtual machines for serving web pages.
Nvidia has the Tegra platform, which you'll be seeing a lot of later this year. It integrates an ARM CPU, an Nvidia GPU, and motherboard chipset functions on a single chip. It is a beautiful piece of work.
It also appears to be winning out over AMD in the high end GPU for non-graphic computations market.
I am not ready to declare the long line of evolution from 8086 chips to be over. They may just absorb what is best, and morph to meet changing user needs. But the competitive dynamics are certainly going to change in the next few years. If Nvidia's Tegra is a competitor, so are chips from Apple, Marvell, Broadcom, Qualcomm, TI, and many others. In fact too many companies have pinned their hopes on ARM processors. Even if ARM becomes the architecture of the future, it is likely that a couple of these companies will gain a marketing or manufacturing advantage, and the field will narrow over time.
Nvidia's best hopes for future profits are probably in specialized graphics processors for high-intensity computing. These may no longer be necessary for the average person's desktop or notebook, but high-end GPUs are subject to much less competition and therefore have higher profit margins on each unit sold.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Applied Materials and NVIDIA correlation
Yesterday I listened to the quarterly analyst conferences for graphic chip maker NVIDIA (NVDA) and semiconductor equipment manufacturer Applied Materials (AMAT). You can see my summaries at:
Applied Materials (AMAT) Q1 Fiscal 2010 analyst conference summary
NVIDIA (NVDA) Q4 Fiscal 2010 analyst conference summary
One data point that matched up was that there is a shortage of key production capacity for semiconductor manufacturing. Nvidia described this as a supply constraint. This is called process technology, and it comes in generations, with less nanometers (nm) being better. 40nm is where Nvidia is at for process technology its newest chips.
The result was a great quarter for semiconductor equipment makers including Applied, which had revenues of $1.85 billion, up 21% sequentially, and up 39% from the year-earlier quarter.
The question for Applied is, how long can this last. Executives were cautious with their guidance, saying it is hard to predict the second half of 2010 at this point. The jump in the quarter that ended January 31 has a lot to do with manufacturers needing to make up for pent up demand. Remember the gloom and doom of January 2009? No one was buying manufacturing equipment; there was plenty of capacity. But designers like Nvidia expect a new generation of smaller chips about every 2 years. So their new products can't even be done on the older processes, which have plenty of capacity.
So two scenarios are possible. One is that with some extra equipment bought in the second half of 2009 and first half of 2010, manufacturers will be up to date on the newer technology. This assumes that the global economy, and in particular the consumer electronics segment of the U.S. economy, grows slowly in 2010.
I think the other scenario is more likely. Demand in nations like India, China, Indonesia, and Brazil will grow rapidly, and the U.S. will ramp moderately, rather than slowly. People are going to want the new smartphones, especially ones that use Marvell's chips to get prices under $125 in Asia. At the same time mobile pushes the small end of web presence, technologies like Nvidia's 3D Vision and AMD's Eyefinity will reinvigorate the large screen segment. Applied Materials makes equipment to manufacture large screen displays, so they should benefit.
All bets on technology involve risks. So ...
Keep diversified!
Applied Materials (AMAT) Q1 Fiscal 2010 analyst conference summary
NVIDIA (NVDA) Q4 Fiscal 2010 analyst conference summary
One data point that matched up was that there is a shortage of key production capacity for semiconductor manufacturing. Nvidia described this as a supply constraint. This is called process technology, and it comes in generations, with less nanometers (nm) being better. 40nm is where Nvidia is at for process technology its newest chips.
The result was a great quarter for semiconductor equipment makers including Applied, which had revenues of $1.85 billion, up 21% sequentially, and up 39% from the year-earlier quarter.
The question for Applied is, how long can this last. Executives were cautious with their guidance, saying it is hard to predict the second half of 2010 at this point. The jump in the quarter that ended January 31 has a lot to do with manufacturers needing to make up for pent up demand. Remember the gloom and doom of January 2009? No one was buying manufacturing equipment; there was plenty of capacity. But designers like Nvidia expect a new generation of smaller chips about every 2 years. So their new products can't even be done on the older processes, which have plenty of capacity.
So two scenarios are possible. One is that with some extra equipment bought in the second half of 2009 and first half of 2010, manufacturers will be up to date on the newer technology. This assumes that the global economy, and in particular the consumer electronics segment of the U.S. economy, grows slowly in 2010.
I think the other scenario is more likely. Demand in nations like India, China, Indonesia, and Brazil will grow rapidly, and the U.S. will ramp moderately, rather than slowly. People are going to want the new smartphones, especially ones that use Marvell's chips to get prices under $125 in Asia. At the same time mobile pushes the small end of web presence, technologies like Nvidia's 3D Vision and AMD's Eyefinity will reinvigorate the large screen segment. Applied Materials makes equipment to manufacture large screen displays, so they should benefit.
All bets on technology involve risks. So ...
Keep diversified!
Labels:
amat,
amd,
applied materials,
eyefinity,
graphics,
Marvell,
nvda,
nvidia,
revenues,
semiconductors,
technology
Sunday, February 15, 2009
TTM Technologies (TTMI) Holds Up
TTM Technologies (TTMI) released its fourth quarter results and held its analyst conference on February 10th. Somewhat to my surprise, revenues are holding up pretty well in the face of what has been a disaster for many technology companies. NVIDIA, for instance, reporting at the same time as TTMI, had revenues for its quarter ending January 25, 2009 down 46% sequentially and down 60% from year earlier [see my Nvidia Q4 fiscal 2009 analyst conference summary for details].
TTM had revenues for its fourth quarter ending December 31, 2008 of $164.9 million, down 2.5% sequentially from $169.0 million and down 1.5% from $167.5 million year-earlier.
TTM's stock price is way down despite its ability to maintain revenue and profit, so it had to write off a bunch of goodwill. This $117 million non-cash charge resulted contributed to a GAAP net loss of $68.5 million.
Normally I like to use GAAP numbers, which are more conservative and realistic than non-GAAP numbers. However, lately a lot of companies have been taking big charges (mostly goodwill impairments) based solely on changes in their stock prices. I think these charges obscure the real picture.
So for TTM it is important to note that excluding the charge and tax benefits from it, non-GAAP net income was $14.5 million. Cash balances at the end of December were $17.1 million higher than at the end of Q3.
Why is TTM doing so much better than NVIDIA and many other technology companies? Both companies have excellent management teams. The main difference is the markets they serve.
TTM makes printed circuit boards, and they are not your grandfather's PCBs. The boards that hold the chips now are technological marvels in themselves, with multiple layers, tiny connecting lines, and holes that are drilled by lasers. You might think that with consumer electronics goods selling poorly, which hurt NVIDIA, a maker high-end graphics chips, PCB manufacturing would be down sharply too. And it is in Asia, where most volume production is done.
TTMs customers tend to need smaller quantitites of PCBs, they often want engineering assistance, and their PCB's are among the hardest to make. They also are constantly engaged in research, which requires prototype PCBs in small numbers with quick turnaround. Cisco is an example of a company that is a top 5 customer for TTM. Cisco is continuing its pace for new product production despite a slump in demand for end products.
TTM also serves military contractors like Northrup and Raytheon. Barack Obama's administration has shown no inclination to back off the military spend that was beefed up for the "war on terror." Military end market revenue is actually growing for TTM and has been for a couple of years.
Could a worsening of this depression hurt TTM? Sure. There is always risk from the economy in any investment.
Might I buy more TTM stock? It is on the short list. It appears to be a reliable source of cash profits. The main risk, it appears, is stock price fluctuation based on fear. With today's market capitalization of $245 million (at $5.73 per share), and $14 million in earnings in a soft quarter, the return on investment is about 23%. You are not going to get that in a corporate bond or treasury. Earnings may go down in the first half of 2009, but they should recover nicely when the economy recovers.
See also my summary of the TTM Technologies analyst conference for Q4 2008.
It is an amazing time to be an investor. TTM is not the only stock that is underpriced. So...
Keep diversifying!
TTM Technologies web site
NVIDIA web site
stock list, analyst conference summaries
TTM had revenues for its fourth quarter ending December 31, 2008 of $164.9 million, down 2.5% sequentially from $169.0 million and down 1.5% from $167.5 million year-earlier.
TTM's stock price is way down despite its ability to maintain revenue and profit, so it had to write off a bunch of goodwill. This $117 million non-cash charge resulted contributed to a GAAP net loss of $68.5 million.
Normally I like to use GAAP numbers, which are more conservative and realistic than non-GAAP numbers. However, lately a lot of companies have been taking big charges (mostly goodwill impairments) based solely on changes in their stock prices. I think these charges obscure the real picture.
So for TTM it is important to note that excluding the charge and tax benefits from it, non-GAAP net income was $14.5 million. Cash balances at the end of December were $17.1 million higher than at the end of Q3.
Why is TTM doing so much better than NVIDIA and many other technology companies? Both companies have excellent management teams. The main difference is the markets they serve.
TTM makes printed circuit boards, and they are not your grandfather's PCBs. The boards that hold the chips now are technological marvels in themselves, with multiple layers, tiny connecting lines, and holes that are drilled by lasers. You might think that with consumer electronics goods selling poorly, which hurt NVIDIA, a maker high-end graphics chips, PCB manufacturing would be down sharply too. And it is in Asia, where most volume production is done.
TTMs customers tend to need smaller quantitites of PCBs, they often want engineering assistance, and their PCB's are among the hardest to make. They also are constantly engaged in research, which requires prototype PCBs in small numbers with quick turnaround. Cisco is an example of a company that is a top 5 customer for TTM. Cisco is continuing its pace for new product production despite a slump in demand for end products.
TTM also serves military contractors like Northrup and Raytheon. Barack Obama's administration has shown no inclination to back off the military spend that was beefed up for the "war on terror." Military end market revenue is actually growing for TTM and has been for a couple of years.
Could a worsening of this depression hurt TTM? Sure. There is always risk from the economy in any investment.
Might I buy more TTM stock? It is on the short list. It appears to be a reliable source of cash profits. The main risk, it appears, is stock price fluctuation based on fear. With today's market capitalization of $245 million (at $5.73 per share), and $14 million in earnings in a soft quarter, the return on investment is about 23%. You are not going to get that in a corporate bond or treasury. Earnings may go down in the first half of 2009, but they should recover nicely when the economy recovers.
See also my summary of the TTM Technologies analyst conference for Q4 2008.
It is an amazing time to be an investor. TTM is not the only stock that is underpriced. So...
Keep diversifying!
TTM Technologies web site
NVIDIA web site
stock list, analyst conference summaries
Labels:
earnings,
net income,
nvda,
nvidia,
PCBs,
printed circuit boards,
revenues,
technology,
TTM Technologies,
TTMI
Monday, June 9, 2008
AMD Revival?
Are AMD's troubles mainly behind it? If they are, the stock price is way to low. But after watching Intel (INTC) swat down AMD with aggressively priced but inferior products, and the subsequent AMD fumbling of the transition to Barcelona quad-core Opteron processors, I can understand why confidence in AMD is not high and could take some time to rebuild. I kept the AMD stock I accumulated, but I have not yet added more to my position despite recent tempting prices.
There are three big variables to look at. One is the competitiveness of AMD's technology. This has many moving parts, including many moving parts at rivals Intel and NVIDIA [NVDA]. The second is financial: what does the hard, historic data look like and tell us about future potential. The third is about markets. A number of nations have accused Intel of using illegal tactics to keep AMD out of the market. And many well-place decision makers own Intel stock. And Intel advertises heavily in the trade journals that help technology purchasers make decisions. As in other businesses, having a better product is no good unless you can develop channels for selling that product.
I think the best way to see the financials is to look at past quarterly reports and analyst conferences. Of course you can look at SEC filings, but for a comprehensible overview I rely on my own analyst conference summaries. Follow this link for a summary of AMD's April 17, 2008 report on the quarter ending March 1. AMD's investor relation page is also useful.
The biggest change over the last year is the decrease in the write-down of ATI acquisition charges. Graphic chip maker ATI was barely holding on against an NVIDIA onslaught when AMD purchased ATI for about $5 billion. Today the combined AMD/ATI operation has a market capitalization of about $4.5 billion. Hence the write-downs. AMD's Q1 cash flow from operations was $16 million, and they generated $50 million more by selling obsolete (to them) tools. More interesting, revenues were $1.505 billion, down 15% sequentially from $1.77 billion, but up 22% from $1.23 billion the year-earlier quarter. The seasonal drop was a bit worse than expected, but the 22% pop from year-earlier seems to show the worst of the revenue slump is behind.
I don't expect anything beyond the normal seasonality for the June quarter. Quad-core Opteron sales should be ramping up, and quad-core Phenom too, but neither have enough technological advantage over Intel's quad-core products to cut much into Intel's market share. The same is true on the discrete graphics processor side, where NVIDIA's domination seems solid in the short run.
Looking down the road 6 months to a year, however, I think AMD is going to be able to leverage its technological leadership over Intel in some key areas. AMD will continue to be the low-energy leader, which is especially important in servers and notebook computers. While Intel has increased the efficiency of its chips (largely by copying AMD) and has a 6-month to a year lead in process technology (the constant shrinking of transistor size on chips), its designs still seem to ignore the needs of end-customers.
The single biggest differentiator, however, is in graphics. AMD's Puma [Turion X2 Ultra] technology for notebooks is the best example. Intel cannot make high-end graphics chips and its low end chips are garbage (and the main reason people complain about Microsoft Vista). AMD Puma builds in a high degree of graphics functionality at a low cost, ideal for low-end notebooks. But for more expensive notebooks, manufacturers can simply add a discrete, high-end, graphics chip. The graphics processing power of the two chips is additive.
Everyone is the industry is afraid of Intel. If Intel cuts off your supply of chips, you are screwed. If Intel raises its prices to you (or gives your competitors better discounts for not using so many AMD chips), you are screwed. There are many large corporate end-users that still have Intel-only policies. Consumers usually do not know what to think about AMD v. Intel, although that is an improvement over 10 years ago, when AMD was assumed to be the inferior brand.
On the other hand, if someone else is selling notebooks that are AMD based (AMD makes the processor, graphics processor, and "glue" chips) that are noticeably better (better graphics, faster processing, longer battery life) than more expensive Intel-based notebooks, that could cause some people to rethink their relationships with the bully boys at Intel.
Of course, the Intel camp is promising wonderful, better than AMD notebook chips real soon. And they will buy enough advertising (and reviewers) to make their propaganda seem true, whether it is or not.
So AMD remains a risky stock. It has a lot of potential. But so far betting on the PC industry showing some backbone against Intel bullying has not paid off, and it may not in the future.
I think Intel is going to have to pony up some money to settle the AMD v. Intel lawsuit. There has just been too much evidence accumulating around the world of Intel wrongdoing. Whether it will be for a half-billion dollars or for $50 billion or any point in between is anyone's guess right now.
There are three big variables to look at. One is the competitiveness of AMD's technology. This has many moving parts, including many moving parts at rivals Intel and NVIDIA [NVDA]. The second is financial: what does the hard, historic data look like and tell us about future potential. The third is about markets. A number of nations have accused Intel of using illegal tactics to keep AMD out of the market. And many well-place decision makers own Intel stock. And Intel advertises heavily in the trade journals that help technology purchasers make decisions. As in other businesses, having a better product is no good unless you can develop channels for selling that product.
I think the best way to see the financials is to look at past quarterly reports and analyst conferences. Of course you can look at SEC filings, but for a comprehensible overview I rely on my own analyst conference summaries. Follow this link for a summary of AMD's April 17, 2008 report on the quarter ending March 1. AMD's investor relation page is also useful.
The biggest change over the last year is the decrease in the write-down of ATI acquisition charges. Graphic chip maker ATI was barely holding on against an NVIDIA onslaught when AMD purchased ATI for about $5 billion. Today the combined AMD/ATI operation has a market capitalization of about $4.5 billion. Hence the write-downs. AMD's Q1 cash flow from operations was $16 million, and they generated $50 million more by selling obsolete (to them) tools. More interesting, revenues were $1.505 billion, down 15% sequentially from $1.77 billion, but up 22% from $1.23 billion the year-earlier quarter. The seasonal drop was a bit worse than expected, but the 22% pop from year-earlier seems to show the worst of the revenue slump is behind.
I don't expect anything beyond the normal seasonality for the June quarter. Quad-core Opteron sales should be ramping up, and quad-core Phenom too, but neither have enough technological advantage over Intel's quad-core products to cut much into Intel's market share. The same is true on the discrete graphics processor side, where NVIDIA's domination seems solid in the short run.
Looking down the road 6 months to a year, however, I think AMD is going to be able to leverage its technological leadership over Intel in some key areas. AMD will continue to be the low-energy leader, which is especially important in servers and notebook computers. While Intel has increased the efficiency of its chips (largely by copying AMD) and has a 6-month to a year lead in process technology (the constant shrinking of transistor size on chips), its designs still seem to ignore the needs of end-customers.
The single biggest differentiator, however, is in graphics. AMD's Puma [Turion X2 Ultra] technology for notebooks is the best example. Intel cannot make high-end graphics chips and its low end chips are garbage (and the main reason people complain about Microsoft Vista). AMD Puma builds in a high degree of graphics functionality at a low cost, ideal for low-end notebooks. But for more expensive notebooks, manufacturers can simply add a discrete, high-end, graphics chip. The graphics processing power of the two chips is additive.
Everyone is the industry is afraid of Intel. If Intel cuts off your supply of chips, you are screwed. If Intel raises its prices to you (or gives your competitors better discounts for not using so many AMD chips), you are screwed. There are many large corporate end-users that still have Intel-only policies. Consumers usually do not know what to think about AMD v. Intel, although that is an improvement over 10 years ago, when AMD was assumed to be the inferior brand.
On the other hand, if someone else is selling notebooks that are AMD based (AMD makes the processor, graphics processor, and "glue" chips) that are noticeably better (better graphics, faster processing, longer battery life) than more expensive Intel-based notebooks, that could cause some people to rethink their relationships with the bully boys at Intel.
Of course, the Intel camp is promising wonderful, better than AMD notebook chips real soon. And they will buy enough advertising (and reviewers) to make their propaganda seem true, whether it is or not.
So AMD remains a risky stock. It has a lot of potential. But so far betting on the PC industry showing some backbone against Intel bullying has not paid off, and it may not in the future.
I think Intel is going to have to pony up some money to settle the AMD v. Intel lawsuit. There has just been too much evidence accumulating around the world of Intel wrongdoing. Whether it will be for a half-billion dollars or for $50 billion or any point in between is anyone's guess right now.
Friday, February 15, 2008
NVIDIA Q4 Glows; Disses ATI & AMD
NVIDIA (NVDA) posted soaring revenue and earnings gains for its 4th quarter of fiscal 2008 ending January 27, 2008. At the analyst conference on February 13, 2008, management told how this was done and predicted a bright future. For details see my NVIDIA analyst conference summary.
Revenues of $1.20 billion were up 7% sequentially from $1.12 billion and up 37% from $879 million year-earlier. Net income of $257.0 milion was up 9% sequentially from $235.7 million and up 57% from $163.5 million year-earlier. Q1 is expected to be down only slightly, instead of the usual seasonal dip.
Management declared this "the era of visual computing." I agree. NVIDIA has led the charge on ever-better graphics processing and presentation capabilities for personal computers. The chips (GPUs, graphics processing units) they sell today are marvellous, and the chips they promise for the future will be even more capable.
Even though everything reduces to 2 dimensions on your LCD screen, for games and other 3-D applications the math processing power needed to make realistic (detailed and fast-changing) scenes is only now beginning to come online. NVIDIAs GeForce 8800 GT GPU has a larger die size and more transistors than most CPU chips. Because of that there was some extra expense in Q4 trying to get good yields of this new top-of-the-line chip out of the fab.
NVIDIA management believes that for most people it now makes more sense to buy a medium or even low-end CPU and combine it with a high-end GPU in order to get maximum use from their computers. This would be especially true if you mainly use your computer for gaming or viewing videos. On the other hand the ability of programmers to find new uses for any extra CPU processing power is a well known trend that is not likely to break up. Right now programmers are behind the curve created by multiple core processors, but I expect new products in 2009 will bring that more into balance. Of course if you have a CPU that mainly just idles while waiting for you to type, even the CPU's of ten years ago are powerful enough. Still, the trend towards doing more computing on the GPU is a good one that will provide programmers with increased flexibility and power.
As to the competition, which is the ATI devision of AMD, NVIDIA management was not worried about them. On the one hand, to illustrate the new trend towards mid-range PCs with high-quality graphics, management picked the Gateway Effects 7020 desktop PC built with an AMD Phenom quad core CPU and an NVIDIA GeForce 8800 GPU.
On the other hand they thought ATI graphics chips are really competitive only in the low-end market, particularly in the low-end notebook computer market. Management went out of its way to dismiss the new X2 cards from ATI as not fast enough and occupying too much space in a computer. These cards have two HD 3870 graphics CPUs on a single card. NVIDIA favors the one-chip per card design, but hedged a bit by saying that they could produce a two-GPU per card competitor if the X2 design catches on. One analyst was surprised enough by this assertion to ask a follow up question and get the same dismissive answer. CNET reviewers, who I respect but sometimes disagree with, said the X2 outscore NVIDIA's GPUs on many games.
I am not a gamer, so I'll leave it to the pros to decide.
NVIDIA is a great technology company and its stock is cheap right now due solely to the liquidity squeeze and global economic uncertainty. I don't own the stock but have been very tempted to buy it lately.
Keep diversified.
See also my NVIDIA (NVDA) main page
Revenues of $1.20 billion were up 7% sequentially from $1.12 billion and up 37% from $879 million year-earlier. Net income of $257.0 milion was up 9% sequentially from $235.7 million and up 57% from $163.5 million year-earlier. Q1 is expected to be down only slightly, instead of the usual seasonal dip.
Management declared this "the era of visual computing." I agree. NVIDIA has led the charge on ever-better graphics processing and presentation capabilities for personal computers. The chips (GPUs, graphics processing units) they sell today are marvellous, and the chips they promise for the future will be even more capable.
Even though everything reduces to 2 dimensions on your LCD screen, for games and other 3-D applications the math processing power needed to make realistic (detailed and fast-changing) scenes is only now beginning to come online. NVIDIAs GeForce 8800 GT GPU has a larger die size and more transistors than most CPU chips. Because of that there was some extra expense in Q4 trying to get good yields of this new top-of-the-line chip out of the fab.
NVIDIA management believes that for most people it now makes more sense to buy a medium or even low-end CPU and combine it with a high-end GPU in order to get maximum use from their computers. This would be especially true if you mainly use your computer for gaming or viewing videos. On the other hand the ability of programmers to find new uses for any extra CPU processing power is a well known trend that is not likely to break up. Right now programmers are behind the curve created by multiple core processors, but I expect new products in 2009 will bring that more into balance. Of course if you have a CPU that mainly just idles while waiting for you to type, even the CPU's of ten years ago are powerful enough. Still, the trend towards doing more computing on the GPU is a good one that will provide programmers with increased flexibility and power.
As to the competition, which is the ATI devision of AMD, NVIDIA management was not worried about them. On the one hand, to illustrate the new trend towards mid-range PCs with high-quality graphics, management picked the Gateway Effects 7020 desktop PC built with an AMD Phenom quad core CPU and an NVIDIA GeForce 8800 GPU.
On the other hand they thought ATI graphics chips are really competitive only in the low-end market, particularly in the low-end notebook computer market. Management went out of its way to dismiss the new X2 cards from ATI as not fast enough and occupying too much space in a computer. These cards have two HD 3870 graphics CPUs on a single card. NVIDIA favors the one-chip per card design, but hedged a bit by saying that they could produce a two-GPU per card competitor if the X2 design catches on. One analyst was surprised enough by this assertion to ask a follow up question and get the same dismissive answer. CNET reviewers, who I respect but sometimes disagree with, said the X2 outscore NVIDIA's GPUs on many games.
I am not a gamer, so I'll leave it to the pros to decide.
NVIDIA is a great technology company and its stock is cheap right now due solely to the liquidity squeeze and global economic uncertainty. I don't own the stock but have been very tempted to buy it lately.
Keep diversified.
See also my NVIDIA (NVDA) main page
Monday, May 14, 2007
AMD Rumble with NVIDIA?
On May 10 NVIDIA (NVDA) reported its first quarter results and had an analysts conference. During it they commented on how well things have gone for the first part of the second quarter. An unexpected outcome was a comment on how well AMD (AMD) channel sales are going.
Today AMD promoted some new products that should help it compete with both Intel and NVIDIA and got a pretty good one-day rise in the price of its stock. Is the future suddenly rosier than investors thought after AMD reported disastrous Q1 results?
Until 2006 there were two major personal computer microprocessor rivals, AMD and Intel (INTC), and two major graphic microprocessor rivals, NVIDIA and ATI. In 2006 AMD bought ATI. But Intel was already a far larger company that AMD, and NVIDIA was considerably larger than ATI. To give some perspective, here are Q1 2007 revenues for the 3 companies:
Intel $8.9 billion
AMD (+ATI) $1.2 billion
NVIDIA $0.8 billion
So in Q1 NVIDIA, which grew 24% from year-earlier, was approaching AMD in size, which shrank revenues 7% from year earlier.
Once it shed its memory division, AMD was mainly a CPU play. OEMs who made AMD based computers bought motherboard chip sets and graphics processors from NVIDIA, ATI, and other suppliers. When AMD bought ATI it gained the ability to engineer chip sets and graphics chips to work will with its microprocessors, but it also made it into a rival of NVIDIA, where before they had been allies. But NVIDIA was already in the same situation versus Intel, which makes its own motherboard chip sets and makes embedded graphics chips, but not the high-end stand alone chips made by NVIDIA and ATI.
So now PC OEMs have some interesting choices. They can go all-Intel for the processor and motherboard, but still give clients the option of adding a graphics card or using an embedded NVIDIA graphics chip. Since the graphics interface is standardized the card can come from NVIDIA or AMD's ATI division. They can go all-AMD. Or they can mix and match. NVIDIA claims, and has clients who agree, that their motherboard chip sets are better than those made by AMD or Intel. If NVIDIA ever decided to make a Microsoft compatible-microprocessor they might dominate the entire field, but that would be a very expensive and risky undertaking. All three companies have some very smart engineers, but it looks to me like the NVIDIA guys have the edge.
In Q1 AMD reported that they had allocated processors to large companies like Dell and HP, but demand was soft there (they did not name a specific company; it may have been more than one). They failed to allocate processors into channel sales (smaller OEMs); by the time they knew they had channel demand and big OEM weakness, it was too late in the quarter to move processors in the right direction.
NVIDIA said they think AMD channel sales are doing better this quarter (which would make sense, if it was just an allocation issue). They think that because their sales of AMD compatible chip sets are up. While it is possible that just means OEMs are just changing chipset partners, most likely it means more PCs with AMD Athlon processors are being sold.
AMD's announcements today were going to come sooner or later, but sooner is better. NVIDIA last week boasted that in April it introduced the first graphics chips that can run DirectX 10; they claimed a huge lead. But he lead was not that big, given that today AMD started selling its Radion HD 2000 series of chip that also supports DirectX 10 and High Definition video play capability.
AMD's true-quad-core chips were demonstrated today, but it will be a while before you can get one. They will be available in server models (Barcellona) and desktop models (Phenom). Intel brought out a quad-core-ish thing in late 2006, but it had two dual-core chips on a socket together. The AMD product is integrated on a single piece of silicon and has integrated memory management, a feature Intel chips continue to lack and a reason Intel chips typically underperform in real world situations.
Except for the enthusiast market I don't see much immediate demand for the quad-core desktop chips. My 2006 vintage AMD Athlon 64 dual-core system runs Windows Vista 64-bit at blazing speeds, allowing me to do my work and play video or music simultaneously. That wonderful feature is a nice demo, but the reality is work and entertainment don't mix well for me. And 1 gigabit of memory has worked very well even when running multiple applications.
The kick for AMD will probably be in the server market where true-quad core with power management and virtualization will be a blessing for anyone running a data center.
Meanwhile, watch for amazing things from NVIDIA. Their graphics computing initiative is just a small sprout now, but I suspect it represents the future of computing.
I own AMD stock but not Intel or NVIDIA stock.
[See also my summaries of recent analyst conferences with Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA.]
[See also corporate web sites for Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA]
Today AMD promoted some new products that should help it compete with both Intel and NVIDIA and got a pretty good one-day rise in the price of its stock. Is the future suddenly rosier than investors thought after AMD reported disastrous Q1 results?
Until 2006 there were two major personal computer microprocessor rivals, AMD and Intel (INTC), and two major graphic microprocessor rivals, NVIDIA and ATI. In 2006 AMD bought ATI. But Intel was already a far larger company that AMD, and NVIDIA was considerably larger than ATI. To give some perspective, here are Q1 2007 revenues for the 3 companies:
Intel $8.9 billion
AMD (+ATI) $1.2 billion
NVIDIA $0.8 billion
So in Q1 NVIDIA, which grew 24% from year-earlier, was approaching AMD in size, which shrank revenues 7% from year earlier.
Once it shed its memory division, AMD was mainly a CPU play. OEMs who made AMD based computers bought motherboard chip sets and graphics processors from NVIDIA, ATI, and other suppliers. When AMD bought ATI it gained the ability to engineer chip sets and graphics chips to work will with its microprocessors, but it also made it into a rival of NVIDIA, where before they had been allies. But NVIDIA was already in the same situation versus Intel, which makes its own motherboard chip sets and makes embedded graphics chips, but not the high-end stand alone chips made by NVIDIA and ATI.
So now PC OEMs have some interesting choices. They can go all-Intel for the processor and motherboard, but still give clients the option of adding a graphics card or using an embedded NVIDIA graphics chip. Since the graphics interface is standardized the card can come from NVIDIA or AMD's ATI division. They can go all-AMD. Or they can mix and match. NVIDIA claims, and has clients who agree, that their motherboard chip sets are better than those made by AMD or Intel. If NVIDIA ever decided to make a Microsoft compatible-microprocessor they might dominate the entire field, but that would be a very expensive and risky undertaking. All three companies have some very smart engineers, but it looks to me like the NVIDIA guys have the edge.
In Q1 AMD reported that they had allocated processors to large companies like Dell and HP, but demand was soft there (they did not name a specific company; it may have been more than one). They failed to allocate processors into channel sales (smaller OEMs); by the time they knew they had channel demand and big OEM weakness, it was too late in the quarter to move processors in the right direction.
NVIDIA said they think AMD channel sales are doing better this quarter (which would make sense, if it was just an allocation issue). They think that because their sales of AMD compatible chip sets are up. While it is possible that just means OEMs are just changing chipset partners, most likely it means more PCs with AMD Athlon processors are being sold.
AMD's announcements today were going to come sooner or later, but sooner is better. NVIDIA last week boasted that in April it introduced the first graphics chips that can run DirectX 10; they claimed a huge lead. But he lead was not that big, given that today AMD started selling its Radion HD 2000 series of chip that also supports DirectX 10 and High Definition video play capability.
AMD's true-quad-core chips were demonstrated today, but it will be a while before you can get one. They will be available in server models (Barcellona) and desktop models (Phenom). Intel brought out a quad-core-ish thing in late 2006, but it had two dual-core chips on a socket together. The AMD product is integrated on a single piece of silicon and has integrated memory management, a feature Intel chips continue to lack and a reason Intel chips typically underperform in real world situations.
Except for the enthusiast market I don't see much immediate demand for the quad-core desktop chips. My 2006 vintage AMD Athlon 64 dual-core system runs Windows Vista 64-bit at blazing speeds, allowing me to do my work and play video or music simultaneously. That wonderful feature is a nice demo, but the reality is work and entertainment don't mix well for me. And 1 gigabit of memory has worked very well even when running multiple applications.
The kick for AMD will probably be in the server market where true-quad core with power management and virtualization will be a blessing for anyone running a data center.
Meanwhile, watch for amazing things from NVIDIA. Their graphics computing initiative is just a small sprout now, but I suspect it represents the future of computing.
I own AMD stock but not Intel or NVIDIA stock.
[See also my summaries of recent analyst conferences with Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA.]
[See also corporate web sites for Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
