Showing posts with label hard drives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hard drives. Show all posts

Monday, April 8, 2013

Dot Hill Ups Guidance, Announces Quantum Parntership

Dot Hill's stock price shot up today on a series of announcements about partners and future guidance, as well as holding its annual analyst day. The last 5 years have been rocky for HILL despite gradual acquisitions of new customers since in lost Sun. In 2012 Dot Hill was developing products that it said would attract new customers [See Dot Hill's 2013 Hopes]. Today was delivery day.

New guidance was given for Q1 2013, Q2 2013, full year-2013, and (tentatively) 2014.

A recap of Q4 2012 provides perspective: revenues were $44.1 million, down 6% from year earlier. Non-GAAP earnings per share (EPS) were negative $0.03, down from $0.00 year-earlier. Not a great quarter.

Prior guidance for Q1 2013 was revenue between $43 and $46 million, with a non-GAAP EPS loss between $0.02 and $0.04.

Today's guidance for Q1 (which should be pretty close, given that the quarter is over) is revenue of $44 to $45 million, narrowing but not increasing the range, with EPS as low as negative $0.02 and as high as $0.00.

$0.00 non-GAAP EPS may not seem like much to get excited about, but that includes research and development costs for new products as well as startup manufacturing costs in costs-of-goods sold. With higher revenue and flat or lower R & D costs going forward, we get to the prettier picture for the future:

Q2 2013 guidance is for revenues between $47 and $53 million, up about 12% sequentially. Non-GAAP EPS estimated range is negative $0.01 to $0.02 per share.

For the full year 2013 revenues are estimated between $205 and $227 million. Non-GAAP EPS should be positive $0.02 to $0.10. That would be great if it happens.

For the full year 2014 revenue estimates are between $231 and $301 million and non-GAAP EPS could be $0.11 to $0.40.

While such long-term predictions should be taken with a healthy spoonful of the salt of cynicism, consider the value of HILL stock if it hit the $0.40 per share top of guidance in 2014. That would likely more than restore investor confidence, so let's give a PE ratio of 15. That would bring the stock to $6 per share. As I write it is trading at $1.53. There are a lot of hoops to jump between $1.53 and $6.00, but there are some reasons to not entirely discount the top range of estimates.

The world of data storage has been evolving rapidly. HILL does not sell disk drives. It sells storage systems for small, medium, and increasingly enterprise businesses. It used to make storage systems for Sun Microsystems until Sun brought a competitor in house. It then picked up HP and NetApp as OEM clients, plus some smaller players and system integrators. Dot Hill dumped NetApp because the margins in the deal was bad, and that made its revenues slump. But all the while it used its substantial cash to develop better systems. Now we are seeing the payoff.

The big announcement today is that Quantum is selling systems, its new QX family, supplied by Dot Hill. A rep from Quantum, at today's Hill analyst conference, reviewed how Quantum has been addressing the rapidly evolving data storage market and how Hill's new products fit into the picture. The amount of data stored in the world is climbing rapidly, largely to accommodate video, full time data feeds, and the mining of big data. Verticals with particular needs to expand their disk drive farms rapidly include entertainment, government, life sciences, and resource extraction (geology). In entertainment many company are rapidly expanding their incoming video feeds, and need all that video instantly for editing and pushing out to consumers. Clients need cheap, reliable storage, and that is what Dot Hill has been developing and is now shipping.

HP, which has provided the bulk of HILL revenues these last few years, has committed to continue using Hill as a supplier of their lower-end, mass market products, the MSA line, the market share leader in its class. While no specifics were mentioned, HP indicated a product refresh is on the horizon. HP has noted Dot Hill systems value, reliability, and interoperability (ability to work with most hardware and software).

The new data storage workloads that are driving the adoption of Hills (patented) technologies are described as a randomized sequential workload. In other words, a lot of data has to be quickly available, and it is hard to predict which data will be needed. However, in a VMWare environment, the new Dot Hill systems were shown to be rock solid reliable and capable of learning about the data demands so as to increase spread over time. With SSD still expensive and tape still much cheaper (using less electricity) than disk drives, the ability to load balance between various media has become a necessity, and Dot Hill does that well.

Also notable is that Dot Hill has greatly increased its addressable market by moving to the higher-end of the data storage market. It is also bringing high-end capabilities to the midrange and even lower range business markets, which makes all of its offering attractive at their price points.

It is an exciting time to be an owner of Dot Hill, but the usual cautions apply: data storage is highly competitive, margins could be better, and the global economy is always an issue.

So keep diversified! And congratulations if you already own HILL stock.

Disclaimer: I own HILL stock. I won't trade HILL stock for at least 3 days from the first publication of this article.

See also:

My Dot Hill main page.

My Q4 2012 Dot Hill conference notes

and of course www.dothill.com

Monday, October 29, 2012

Marvell (MRVL) Wins Microsoft Surface RT Wi-Fi slot

Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) won a slot in the Microsoft Surface tablet computer. According to Anandtech (Inside Microsoft's Surface RT Tablet, October 16, 2012), the WiFi chip on the tablet is Marvell's. NVIDIA won the main prize with its Tegra 3 ARM-based processing chip. Atmel also had chips in the design.

We don't know how many of the WiFi chips Marvell shipped to Microsoft in the summer quarter (Marvell's fiscal Q3 2013 ending October 27, 2012), but it was not enough to balance the damage in the hard disk drive (HDD) controller chip business. Marvell dominates HDD controller chips, but the problem is that the largest single use of HDDs in in PCs. It was a terrible quarter for PC sales, and little HDD makers Seagate and Western Digital could do about it.

Marvell had guided revenues to $800 to $850 million. The update issued on October 18 put revenues at $765 to $785 million. At the midpoint there is a $25 million miss on the low end of prior guidance. Just about all of that came from the HDD segment. Marvell also makes chips for smartphones, for networking (ranging from WiFi to high-end datacenter Ethernet), for Google TV and similar appliances, and for video processing in HD TVs. It is moving into new areas like LED controllers.

The fourth quarter is a big question mark. A lot depends on the global outlooks of OEMs. If they are pessimistic they may further shrink inventories. If holiday sales go well, they may have to expand inventories, giving chip manufacturers like Marvell a boost.

While there is a lot of uncertainty about Q4 and about 2013, Marvell is well set to manage their way through it and eventually expand into new businesses, as they have in the past. Even at the current level of revenue Marvell is a cash cow. At the current stock price, $7.755 at the close Friday, you are buying $0.75 in trailing 12-month earnings and dividends of $3.1% per year, plus a cash balance of $2.13 billion, or $3.82 per share. In the latest quarter cash flow from operations was $0.34 per share. It looks to me like the market over-reacted to the revenue miss. At this price Marvell stock is well worth the risk, in my opinion. But then I started accumulating Marvell stock years ago.

Marvell is large enough and diverse enough that if only moderate numbers of Microsoft Surface tablets get sold, that probably won't have a significant impact on Marvell revenue or profit. Then again, the Windows Surface is a really hot device, and may sell in more than moderate numbers. It is on my wish list.

Disclaimer: I am long Marvell and Seagate. I will make no position changes in them for a week after this article is published. I do not have a position in Microsoft, Western Digital or NVIDIA and also will not initiate one for a week. Also, I occasionally do freelance work for Microsoft.

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Adept Technology (ADEP) Initial Look

Adept Technology is a Pleasanton, California based maker of robotic machines for materials handling. I was mentioned in a New York Times article recently, which I read because of my interest in robots and artificial intelligence. I decided to take a look at the company as a potential investment. Yesterday Adept (ADEP) released its June quarter (fiscal Q4) results, and I listened to the analyst conference. You can read my notes at: Adept Technology fiscal Q4 2012 notes.

The first thing that individual investors should note is the Adept has a small market capitalization and is not yet profitable. Revenue in the quarter was substantial, however, at $17 million. Net income was negative $360,000, which is within sight of break-even. However bright the future of robotics and Adept might be, it needs to be treated as a risky stock. The stock price ran up after the Times article, and is falling today along with most of the market. Right now it is at $4.30, which would give it a market capitalization of $45.3 million.

I certainly don't consider a young technology company with an annual revenue run rate approaching $70 million to be overpriced when the market cap is $45.3 million and it is running near break-even.

Judging mainly from the conference, Adept makes three basic types of robots, all of which are based on artificial intelligence applied to video, as well as the usual need to manipulate the robots themselves. It mainstay is robots used in the manufacture of hard disk drives.

It has also introduced robots for handling semiconductor wafers, and has a first client for these mobile robots in Singapore.

A third line is designed to rapidly pack agricultural products in plastic clamshell packaging, and there is a California company that is the first customer and proving ground for this product.

It is tempting to plunge in and buy an initial stake of ADEP, but I am going to follow my usual path of being patient and doing more research. There are many robotics companies already, and while there are a lot of applications that could benefit from robots, it is important to understand the competition. Also, I need to read the more recent SEC filings, which I have not done yet.

I already own stock in a medical robotics company, Hansen Medical, and in a manufacturer of microcontrollers used in robotics, Microchip.

I should mention that Adept raised $3 million in the quarter through a new stock issue, and has less than $9 million in cash on hand. In addition to stock dilution through stock-based compensation, there could be a need to raise more cash.

Going forward, I would hope to see better margins on the newer robot lines. If they are valuable to customers, they should be valuable enough to price at a point where there are profit margins for Adept. Otherwise they are just having fun with robots and are not an investment-grade company.

My initial impression of Adept Technologies is very positive overall. At the same time there are a lot of alternatives for my (or your) investment cash. If I do start buying Adept I probably will report that only after the fact. Often I follow stocks for years without ever buying in.

Disclaimer: I have no relationship to ADEP and currently do not own stock. I may buy ADEP at any point without prior notice

See also: http://www.adept.com/

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Marvell Technology (MRVL) Elbows Out

Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) reported results above expectations for the quarter ending April 28 (Q1 fiscal 2013) last Thursday. I was delighted that CEO Sehat Sutardja strayed from his usual dry, careful observations to take on some negative Street views of his company.

Revenue was $795.4 million, up 7% sequentially from $742.7 million, but down 1% from $802.4 million year-earlier. That may not seem stellar, but some rival semiconductor companies and some analysts had been predicting considerably worse. Essentially the rumors were that a competitor was finally besting Marvell in the hard drive controller market and that Marvell was also failing in the Chinese smartphone market.

Marvell stock ended Thursday, before results were released, at $13.3. Today it closed at $12.99, for a market capitalization of $7.4 billion. Clearly the news that Marvell is back on the success track has not yet sunk in, with overall market turmoil probably not helping.

For investors the last few year with Marvell have been tough. After splitting in 2004 and again in 2006, the stock price entered 2007 at well over $20 per share. At the 2008 bottom it hit a low around $4.48. More recently Marvell's 52-week high was $16.86, low was $11.23.

The real long-term value in any technology company is as much in what is going on in its R&D department today as what last-quarter's results were. R&D spend in the latest quarter was a healthy $256 million. Marvell does not give a breakdown of R&D spend, but a lot of it had to go to two crucial areas where Marvell leads competitors: TD smartphones for the Chinese market and next generation storage devices, including both HDD (hard disk) and SDD (flash memory based).

The main good news for Q1 was the continued rapid ramping of sales of Marvell-processor based TD-SCDMA smartphones in China. Marvell's chips not only include the processor, but most of the functions needed to run a smartphone (graphics, cellular modem, wi-fi, bluetooth). The middle-class masses are buying Android based smartphones that run on a this new 3G high-speed, invented-in-China protocol. Revenue from these chips was up 25% from Q4. Usually, for its mobile sector, Marvell sees a seasonal decline from Q4 to Q1, and indeed overall the sector was down 1% sequentially. Even then Marvell's mobile segment revenue was up 14% from year-earlier Q1.

Marvell has not competed very successfully for silicon in smartphones in the U.S. or Europe. It has space in some RIM Blackberry phones. When RIM tanked analysts predicted Marvell would have to abandon the space. Instead Marvell is turning its clear victory in China to its advantage in the global competition for the next generation of smartphones. Qualcomm's control of CDMA patents may be history as LTE becomes the new standard. I don't see Marvell beating out Qualcomm in the U.S. or Europe in the next few years, but its design philosophy is enabling it to turn the flank in China, much of Asia, and Africa.

In the hard drive space Sutardja specifically took on the claims of its chief competitor (LSI) about capturing market share, claims that have been echoed by several Wall Street analysts without fact checking. Marvell's storage sector revenue was up over 20% sequentially, in what is usually a seasonally sequentially down quarter. This sequential growth was only partly due to industry recovery from the Thailand floods.

After the floods Marvell's market share did drop to 56%, according to Sutardja. But that was based on which HDD makers were hurt worst by the flooding, not by the competitiveness of Marvell's controller chip rival. In Q2 quarter Marvell's market share should return to about 60%. The disruption of the industry in 2011 meant people produced whatever capacity drives they could. This quarter will see return to normalcy, which means favoring higher-capacity drives for any units that can be produced. Marvell leads in controller chips for high-capacity drives, including the new 500 GB/platter mobile drive solution, which is expected to ramp revenue another 50% in the current quarter. Sutardja also pledged to gain unit and revenue share going forward based on next-generation designs.

There are a lot of other pieces to the Marvell enterprise, but a good summary would be the guidance issued for fiscal Q2 2013 end July, 2012: 6 to 12% sequential revenue increase, or $840 to $890 million. A bit above the upper end of the range would put Marvell flat y/y.

While revenue has flattened since 2010, profit generation has been very healthy at these levels. As a result Marvell initiated a $0.06 per share per quarter dividend. $500 million was added to the share repurchase program. The cash balance was $2.2 billion.

Marvell would be able to buy back a substantial portion of its shares at its current share price.

The usual risks apply. Marvell faces competition in every market it serves, in particular chips for smartphones. My best guess, however, is that over the long run Marvell will continue to do what it did after its founding: take market share from rivals. It will also continue its expansion into new sectors.

Disclaimer: I am long Marvell. I seldom trade the stock and won't for a week after this article is published.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Opportunities in Data Storage: Seagate, Western Digital, and Marvell

Because I own stock in Marvell Technologies (MRVL), which gets about half of its revenue from sales of HDD controller chips, I read a detailed interview with Steve Luczo, the CEO of Seagate Technology (STX) [See Seagate CEO Interview at Forbes]. Seagate is one of only 2 remaining major hard disk drive (HDD) manufacturers. The other is Western Digital (WDC). While I already agreed with the overall HDD story, Steve made some very good points that I had not thought of or heard before.

In addition to MRVL and STX, I'll be discussing semiconductor manufacturing capital equipment makers Applied Materials (AMAT) and KLA (KLAC) as well as Dot Hill (HILL), EMC, AMD, and Intel (INTC).

Let's tackle the Thailand flooding aftermath before taking on long-term trends. Industry-wide, quarterly unit sales were projected to be 180 million before the floods hit. Instead Q4 2011 production was 120 million units. Q1 production rose to 140 million units, Q2 expectations are 160 million units, and Q3 should be back to 180 million. If there are still shortages, Q4 could see between 180 and 200 million units produced.

In addition, as the year progresses industry average drive capacity will increase as new, high-capacity equipment replaces older machines damaged by the flooding.

For makers of parts that go into the drives, that is good news. It is also good news for PC and server manufacturers (and suppliers like AMD and Intel (INTC)) that have been constrained by HDD shortages. In Marvell's case, they report quarters with a one-month lag and also ship pre-production. That means that Marvell is currently in a quarter that runs February to April. April chips will go in May HDDs, so run rates should be pretty good by then. It is possible that Marvell's July quarter will be back to record HDD controller chip shipments.

Overall expectations are that once we get past Q1, this should be a banner year for almost everyone in the storage industry, with good margins (because shortages will persist) and unit shipments improving markedly in the second half.

But aren't Solid State Drives (SSD's) going to replace HDDs, which are not used in tablet computers, smartphones, or possibly in thin and light notebook models? Should investors continue to flee the entire HDD industry? Why else, except investor flight, would Seagate have a forward P/E of just 4.1?

Luczo does not think so. The anti-HDD argument that has been around investor circles for some time is that as SSDs become mass-market, and technologies shrink, SSD capacities will go up, prices will come down, and HDD demand will decline in short order.

The typical counter argument is that data storage requirements are based on the expanding storage needs of the world. Storage is a volume business, so while SSDs may provide speed, HDDs need to continue to improve both capacity and units shipped just to keep up with expanding volumes of data, particularly video data. For every iPad there has to be disk capacity in the cloud somewhere, because iPads mostly need to connect to data stored on disks in the cloud to be useful.

The stronger argument is this: semiconductor fabs cannot be built fast enough to make the SSD replacing HDD dream come true, not anytime soon, if ever.

A new semiconductor fab (factory) is a very expensive investment at $10 billion. If the chips produced by the fabs (in this case mainly memory chips) are not expensive enough, building a new fab is a money loser. In effect the prices for chips are set by the capital required to build the fabs.

It is much, much cheaper to add data storage production capacity, on a byte basis, by building new HDD factories than by building new semi fabs. The same data capacity expansion could be achieved with less than $1 billion in capital, Thus HDDs will have a considerable price advantage for the reasonably visible future.

Technology investors have learned that when a technology is dying, you might as well exit. Some companies role well from one technology generation to another, as Intel has. But the point here is that the HDD industry is not dying. The SSD industry can grow rapidly for an entire decade and the HDD industry will still be far larger at the end of the decade than it is today, and than the SSD industry will be. Of course many companies will play both sides of the SSD/HDD game, and hybrid drives are already available.

But suppose Luczo is wrong in the sense that chip manufacturers do decide to invest rapidly in fabs to drive as much SSD expansion as quickly as possible. I still think Seagate is undervalued in that scenario, but there would be other winners. The obvious ones are the semiconductor equipment manufacturers whose machines make the silicon wafers and create the tiny transistors that make up Flash memory. There are still a number of companies in this category, but as capital requirements increase this segment is consolidating as well. Two big players that should gain from SSD fab accelerations are Applied Materials (which recently acquired Varian), and KLA-Tencor. Both currently have attractive P/Es that do not reflect any future boom in the SSD industry.

Meanwhile data storage equipment makers from giants like EMC and HP to specialists like Dot Hill should continue to do well, since the systems they manufacture can accommodate both SSDs and HDDs, depending on the needs of the end customers.

Disclaimer: I own MRVL, AMAT, and HILL. I do not own STX, WDS, KLA, INTC, or EMC. I won't trade in any of these stocks for 3 days after this article is published.

Keep diversified!

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Dot Hill Expects New OEM Customers in 2012

Dot Hill (HILL) is up today after reporting a poor fourth quarter 2012 yesterday. Q4 results were in line with revised guidance given in February. Today's stock price upside came from new customer sign-ups that management hopes will provide both higher revenues and better margins in 2012.

Dot hill manufactures data storage arrays for the low-end of the enterprise market, selling to OEMs that typically rebrand the devices. A few years ago Sun was their main customer, but Sun dropped them, leading to a crisis. HP is now their main customer. While they are happy with the HP relationship, which was extended for five years last year, management has been building an impressive list of other customers, reducing reliance on HP.

Revenue in Q4 was $47.0 million, down 2% sequentially from $48.1 million and down 28% from $65.4 million year-earlier. Part of the y/y decline resulted from the purposeful ditching of NetApp as a client because NetApp would not allow Dot Hill workable margins.

HP represented 67.5% of revenue in Q4. In Q1 2011, after NetApp dropped out, HP accounted for 76% of revenue. Partly there was a drop in revenue from HP, but mainly their share shrank because Hill's sales to smaller, Tier 2 OEMs grew 40% y/y.

Q4 revenue was also hurt by the Thailand flooding and resulting shortage of disk drives. Hill did not raise its prices in Q4, but did raise prices in February largely because of the higher prices of disks due to the shortage. They estimated they could have generated another $4 million in revenue in Q4 if not for the disk shortages. Q1 also has seen supply shortages, but drives are generally available except for the highest-capacity, newest technology drives. The disk supply issue should be over by Q3.

Autodesk and Concurrent Computer were cited as OEMs signed in 2011 that are seeing sales ramps. Official announcements of newer customers should be coming out as the year progresses.

Finally, new storage arrays that have mid-level enterprise features should be released in the second half of the year. OEMs are already excited about them, but a significant revenue ramp of the new products is probably a 2013 story.

Earnings were disappointing. GAAP net income was negative $6.6 million, non-GAAP net income was negative $1.6 million, but some of the charges were non-cash. Cash flow from operations was positive by $1.1 million.

On the whole Dot Hill management was upbeat, particularly about the second half of 2012. The hope would be that with no disasters, a reasonably healthy global economy, and the ramping of lines at newer OEM customers, Dot Hill will be able to enter an era of sustained profitability. Given that the company is debt free and holds $46 million in cash, and that its market capitalization today is just $82.6 million, Dot Hill is highly speculative, but has a lot of upside potential if management can execute according to plan.

Disclaimer: I am long Dot Hill, and sometimes actively trade in the stock. I won't make HILL trades for 1 week after publishing this article. I do not have positions in any of the other companies mentioned.

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Will Thailand Floods Hit Marvell Technology?

Marvell Technology (MRVL) makes semiconductor chips for hard disk drives (HDDs), cell phones, networking and other devices. Marvell's first product was a chip to control hard drives, and in its first decade it came to dominate that market. This year revenue from chips for hard drives has represented about half of total Marvell revenue.

This week massive flooding in Thailand caused Western Digital manufacturing facilities to be shut down there. Obviously this could hurt demand for Marvell's HDD controller chips, at least temporarily. How much trouble could this be for Marvell's Q3 and Q4 results? (its fiscal Q3 ends October 30th; Q4 ends January 31st)

Western Digital is currently Marvell's largest HDD customer. Earlier this year Western Digital acquired Hitachi's HDD division. Marvell is generally granted to have the best HDD controller chips, so it has been expected to expand its already substantial market share by increasingly supplying chips for Hitachi. It has also been becoming a more important supplier for another big HDD manufacturer, Seagate, which is acquiring Samsung's HDD division. In Q1 2011 Western Digital led global shipment in units, but Seagate led in revenues.

According to Western Digital, two of its Thailand facilities were shut because of flooding. In addition there has been flood damage to the supply chain for the plants. It expects a "significant impact" on its ability to meet demand in the December quarter.

Seagate's Thai factories were not directly affected, but it also expects supply chain problems of unknown magnitude.

While all this is sorted out Marvell will probably lose some October shipments, which may impact Q3 revenue, depending on revenue recognition timing. It is too early to predict how long beyond October the effect could last. In the longer run it is likely just a bump in the road. There is inventory at every stage of the chain. HDD sales have not been robust this year, so the inventory situation is probably not bad. PC manufacturers have inventory on hand, and there have been no reports that the flooding ruined any drives already made or in production. To some extent supplies and production could be shifted to other plants, which should have excess capacity, if not now (gearing up for holiday PC sales), certainly in December and January.

The situation is worth watching. If it takes months instead of weeks to get back to full production there could be a substantial impact on Marvell's Q4 results. On the other hand Marvell has been trending to be less reliant on HDD chip sales for its profits. Revenues from its Chinese smartphone chips, which should be ramping in Q3, are probably the best indicator of how well Marvell will fare in 2012.

Disclosure: I am long Marvell Technology (MRVL).

See also: http://www.marvell.com/
My August 18, 2011 Marvell (MRVL) analyst call summary
My May 26, 2011 Marvell (MRVL) analyst call summary
My March 2011 Marvell (MRVL) analyst call summary
Keep diversified!

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Marvell Technology: What Inflection Point?

Marvell Technology (MRVL) makes semiconductor chips for hard disk drives, cell phones, networking and telecommunications. Although for the most part Marvell has had a brilliant run since it was founded in 1995, recently the going has been rough, as reflected in its stock price. After a 52-week high of $22.87 last April, the stock closed at $15.81 yesterday, then bounced back a bit today. The release of quarter results on Thursday (the 3rd) and the analyst conference call caused a big sell off Friday, to $16.13, after closing Thursday at $18.22.

Should Marvell be abandoned, or is this a buying opportunity?

First, keep in mind that Marvell has a fiscal year that ends on January 30th. Their Q4s are typically seasonally slower than their Q3s because shipments of chips going into devices sold over the holidays typically are made in Q3. Q1 fiscal 2012 will end at the end of April; Q2 at the end of July; Q3 at the end of October.

On the other hand, a technology company with rapidly ramping revenues can sometimes overcome seasonal declines. Marvell has lined up two sequential q/q declines. In Q2 revenues were $896.5 million; in Q3 $959.3 million; in Q4 $900.5 million; and for Q1 guidance is for $800 to $850 million. That is worse than normal seasonality.

Last year Marvell CEO Sehat Sutardja, at the Marvell March 4, 2010 analyst conference call, predicted that Marvell would reach an "upward inflection point" within the next twelve months. We seem to be in a downward deflection point instead. Now Mr. Sutardja is saying that revenues (and profits) will ramp again in the second half of this year (more precisely, the second half of fiscal 2012). Should we discount his prediction, given he made it before and reality proved him wrong?

Let's look at why the prior inflection point prediction went awry. The hard drive market was not as robust as expected, mainly because global PC sales did not grow much in 2010. Marvell already has more than half of the market for the controller and other chips in hard drives, and in the latest quarter those still accounted for almost half of Marvell's revenue. Even with new products ramping up, the decline in hard drive chip revenue put a big dent in projections. Marvell is competitive in controllers for solid state drives too, but is not dominant there.

The other problem was Research in Motion (RIM), although Sehat did not mention them by name, everyone knew which customer he was talking about. It isn't that RIM (maker of Blackberry phones) is itself in trouble, despite competition from Apple and Android-based devices. Marvell makes chips for only a couple of RIM models. For those models there was an inventory issue, not with too much inventory, but with a change that results in Marvell holding inventory for RIM. The main issue is that in many developing nations RIM is moving 2.5G phones, and Marvell does not have a chip for 2.5G. However, Marvell should have such a chip later this year.

So two major sources of revenue Marvell counted on were down in Q4 and will continue to be down in Q1. But the big issue, the lack of an inflection point, has to do with OPhones in China. These phones sold slowly late in 2010. Sehat believes that is mainly a matter of introducing them and prices that were too high on the original models. During 2011 a number of Marvell based OPhones will be introduced in China at far more attractive prices, yet which maintain Marvell's own profit margins.

Hence, still an upward inflection point. I don't blame potential Marvell investors to take a wait and see approach. The problem (with not buying at today's stock price) is that Marvell, even in these "bad" quarters, is generating a lot of cash. The low price/earnings ratio for the stock reflects the "show me" attitude about OPhones. If you wait for the revenue ramp to be in the rear-view mirror, the stock is going to be a lot more expensive.

So watch for OPhone news out of China. Maybe consumers there will want iPhones or other alternatives instead. But if hundreds of millions buy the new Marvell-based OPhones, Sehat and crew are going to look a lot more far-sighted than they do right now.

I own Marvell stock and understand the risk of competing against the talented people at Qualcomm, NVIDIA, Apple, etc. Right now I would not sell my Marvell stock for less than $30 per share. Come this fall, depending on the OPhone ramp, I may need to change my estimate of its value.

See also:

http://www.marvell.com/

My March 2011 Marvell (MRVL) analyst call summary

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Marvell Rumors: Hard Drives, RIM PlayBook

If you own a hard drive, odds are better than even that it has a Marvell Technology Group chip running it. In fact Marvell is a key supplier of many semiconductor devices that go into cell phones, wireless and hardwired networking equipment, and printers.

When Marvell's stock price began to slump yesterday (it closed Monday at $17.21, closed Tuesday at $16.89, down almost 2%), on a day the rest of the market was booming upward, I figured it was because of concerns about the hard disk drive (HDD) business. Reports from the field are that notebook sales are off, as 2 million consumers a month buy iPad tablets instead of refreshing their older notebooks. Less notebook computers means less hard drives, and PC sales in general have not been robust so far this year.

But no, a rumor was floating around, apparently originating with a noted Wall Street analyst, Ashok Kumar of Rodman & Renshaw, that RIM had dumped MRVL for TI for its processor for the PlayBook tablet computer. The rumor made some sense but had some obvious problems too. All stories I found on the net had the same origin, but many managed to deviate from the original, one even calling the RIM PlayBook the BlackPad (RIM is best known for its BlackBerry devices).

Executives of listed corporations are not supposed to give individual analysts market moving news. They are supposed to give all analysts and investors any market-moving news at the same time, usually by a press release or a public conference call. But analysts do all kinds of things to try to figure out what is going to happen before it is announced. I know I do. When I heard the RIM PlayBook announced, I looked to see who made the processor. No answer, but it was an ARM-based processor. As a Marvell investor I hoped my company would have a win, and many other commentators thought that was a good guess.

But RIM and their partners kept the design a secret, so in fact no one should have assumed Marvell won design-in. There are lots of uber-competent ARM-based processor makers to choose from.

So far there has been no confirmation from Marvell, RIM, or TI of the story. Which means it may not be true. Analysts like to have sources in or near companies. We like to ask questions to one company that will give us insight into the financial future of other companies. TI may very well have a design win at RIM, but it may not have ever been a socket Marvell had already won.

Let's look at the rumor as stated. The PlayBook release has been delayed; that much is known true. That would mean there are development problems. Kumar is alleged to have said the QNX OS for the device had problems, and the Marvell Armada chip for the device had bugs.

Let's see, Marvell chips work fine on BlackBerry phones already, and they work fine on Android phones. So was this a new, as yet untested chip that was buggy? Or was it just hard to integrate with the new QNX OS system? That is a classic engineering problem, with the software guys blaming hardware, and the hardware guys blaming software. If there was a Marvell chip screw up, was it really the chip, or was the incompetence on the RIM team? And why would a TI chip, also based on the same ARM design, work right off with QNX? Is it easier to fix known, discovered bugs, or to start over with a new chip? Usually, it is easier to fix the known bugs. And usually you don't change the processor, because that would require a lot more work than changing the OS to work around the processor's capabilities.

One way a possibly partly true, but obviously flawed, rumor can happen is through the third party. TI guy says to a friend, we got a RIM contract! Friend digs deeper, just a purely tech conversation, and speculation is RIM had some problem with QNX, and Marvell was the team to beat. By the time Friend, who is a regular supplier of tech information, talks to Kumar, the story makes sense, but may not be factually based. Kumar tries to verify the story, but if RIM, TI, or MRVL tells him, they are violating confidentiality contracts and SEC rules, so they don't comment. Kumar goes with his story. If he's right, he's a genius. If he is wrong, the squirrels will forget it soon enough.

At some point an official announcement may be made. Other than that, I'll have to wait until one of my friends gets a PlayBook and pops it open to see what chips are inside.

More data:

Marvell site

My Marvell Technology (MRVL) page

Marvell fiscal Q2 2010 results release

Monday, May 24, 2010

Marvell Profits from R&D

In most of the computer and electronics industry the 3rd and 4th quarters are hot. Then Q1, and Q2 are seasonally down. Not that much is selling; inventory is being built for back-to-school, then for the consumer holiday spree and and-of-year corporate buying. This year so far is trending a bit different for many electronic parts suppliers because of the rapid recovery from the 2009 business panic. Judging from its quarter ending May 1, 2010 (its first fiscal quarter of 2011), Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) is benefitting from more than just industry trends.

Marvell first came to dominate the hard drive semiconductor chip industry, and those chips still account for over half of Marvell's revenue. Marvell engineers lead in combining analog and digital chip functions, so we are seeing market penetration in areas where this is an advantage. So far this has been in wired and wireless networking chips and in cell phones, particularly in smartphones. Marvell makes chips for Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, for the wireless signal that connects to cell towers, and for application processors that give the phones their ability to act like computers. While its entry into this market is relatively recent, it is already a major player.

In Q1 Revenue was $856 million, up 2% sequentially from $842.5 million and up 64% from $521 million in the year-earlier quarter. The mobile and wireless end market accounted for about 22% of revenue, so about $188 million. The segment grew 18% sequentially, and that despite Wi-Fi chips "only" growing 6% sequentially.

What is most likely to happen in the next few quarters is that wired networking and storage chips will do their usual annual ramp based on demand, plus any market share gain. Smartphone revenue will continue its explosive growth as a larger number of phones using Marvell's chips are brought to market. And the ramp will include chips for oPhones in China, which by 2011 should, by themselves, be a major source of revenue for Marvell.

In a normal market, Marvell would have a high PE ratio because of its track record and future prospects. But this is no normal market. It is a fear-driven, better a 0% treasury than a 8% stock market. It's pretty weird. Who knows, maybe the world will end and we will sink into an economic depression. But I have news for you. In that case, U.S. treasuries will be as worthless as stocks, because there will be no way the government can raise enough in taxes to cover interest payments.

I own Marvell stock to my portfolio rules limit. I could be wrong, maybe a competitor or two will best Marvell in some segment of the market, but I believe the most probable outlook is that in a few years everyone will wish they had bought Marvell in 2009 or the spring of 2010.

That's my opinion. You can also get the facts, as management presents them, by reading my Marvell MRVL analyst conference summaries.

And of course see also www.marvell.com

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Dot Hill Potential and Pitfalls

Dot Hill, which makes data storage equipment sold by HP, NetApp, and other OEMs, is a very interesting story these days. If you were to just look at the numbers, you would think the stock price is too low. If you know its history of of always seeming to find its way to losses out of the jaws of profits, you can understant the lack of investor enthusiasm.

I think management has been making the right moves, but we probably won't see the proof (or disproof) of it until 2011.

Dot Hill makes hard disk arrays for business class data storage. This is not a high margin business. In the latest quarter ending Dec. 31, 2009 revenues were $62.6 million, but cost of goods sold was $53.6 million, leaving a gross profit of $9.0 million, or a gross margin of just 14.4% of revenue. Even though the the company is run efficiently, spending only $3.1 million on marketing, $6.8 million on research and development, and $2.6 million on general and administrative, this led to an overall GAAP loss of $5.0 million in the quarter. Take out a $1.5 restructuring charge and some non-cash costs and the non-GAAP loss was still $3 million.

As I said, this kind of near-miss has been going on at HILL for as long as I can remember. So why do I own the stock? Partly because I have been buying on dips, but there is also a long-term method to my investment.

First, Sun used to be the only major client, but Sun bought its own storage company and is now being absorbed in Oracle. Despite revenues from sales to Sun being less than 1% of revenue, this change did not lead to Hill's demise. Hill designed storage arrays that NetApp and HP are very happy with. If not for the recession, Dot Hill might have been profitable in 2009. I believe revenues will ramp in 2010, partly from more OEMs coming on board. Even if gross margins don't improve, it should become easier to cover operating costs out of gross profit.

At least as important is Dot Hill's determination to raise its gross margins. The main way this will be done is by selling software to manage the hardware along with the hardware. They have already begun doing this, but they are also acquiring Cloverleaf, which has the right software for this job.

Of course acquiring Cloverleaf will take some cash, and operating expenses will go up as well. More sales expense and more R&D expense will preceed the bulk of the software revenue. The next two quarters probably won't look that great. But hopefully by Q3 or Q4 of 2010 we will see software revenues ramping appreciably. Software revenues should have gross margins above 60%, maybe well above that by 2011.

If the scenario works out, that would change the picture entirely. Dot Hill would still have roughly $50 million in cash with no debt. It should hit a revenue run rate of over $300 million per year by the end of 2010. And with improved gross margins, it should start generating a profit. I see no reason why a 4% operating profit on revenue can't be achieved in 2011.

So what would that make the company worth? A lot more than the $81.6 million in market capitalization (at $1.51 per share) that Dot Hill ended today with.

But this scenario has its risks. Will the end users accept the software? Could HP or NetApp drop Dot Hill for a different supplier? Will more OEMs sign up? Will the economy hold up?

If you are going to invest in risky stocks, no matter how golden the upside looks, remember to:

Keep Diversified!

More data:

www.dothill.com
My Dot Hill main page
Q4 2009 Dot Hill analyst conference summary

Monday, March 8, 2010

Marvell Sees Inflection Point

Marvell Technology Group, Ltd. (MRVL) is led by Sehat Sutardja, who built the company on his invention of a better chip to enable hard disk drives. Marvell has been the leading (by market share) supplier of hard drive controller chips for years, and this segment still represented 50% of revenue for the latest quarter. Marvell has also branched out to a variety of newer areas, based on its ability to combine analog functions and digital functions on a single chip (called SoC, for System on Chip).

Marvell was hit hard by the recession: in fiscal Q4 2009, ending January 30, 2009, it had $512 million in revenues, down from a peak of $843 million in the quarter ending August 2, 2008.

Last week Marvell reported for fiscal Q4 2010, ending January 30, 2010, revenues of $842 million. GAAP net income was an amazing $205 million; cash flow from operations was $281 million.

But the future, while speculative, could be even more amazing. Sehat referred to a coming inflection point. An inflection point on a curve can be from going down to up or vice versa, but in this case he is talking about a dramatic increase is Marvell's revenue growth rate.

As I have pointed out in the past, Marvell spent a lot of money on research and development in the earlier part of this decade, and only cut back a little during the recession. This year new products that were sampled in 2009 are ramping into volume production, and new products sampling this year are going to ramp in 2011. What are those new products?

Most notable are "communication processors" for smart phones, particularly the oPhone beginning to be sold in China. In order to get a price point low enough for mass marketing in China, more features than ever before had to be integrated into a single semiconductor chip. Marvell is unique in being able to offer general application and signal processing, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, graphics, and cellular modem. Over 90% of oPhone models (there are several companies building them) use Marvell chips.

This alone could be sufficient to cause the inflection point. While the oPhones are far less expensive than models sold in the U.S., Marvell gets very good profit margins on the chips it makes for them. Start multiplying these per-chip margins by the 100s of millions of likely oPhone buyers in China, and you can see the potential.

But there is more. Marvell has become an increasingly prominent player in high-speed Internet switching chips. The competition there is intense, but intense competition has not impeded Marvell for very long in other fields it has chosen to enter.

Many of the newer products will be based on a microprocessor line called Armada. The thing about Marvell is that unlike Intel, they usually don't just make a microprocessor and sell it to customers who put it in a socket. Marvell works with manufacturers to integrate exactly what they need for their products on a single chip that incorporates the microprocessor. This gives faster execution and communication times and reduces costs, while leaving Marvell an ample profit margin.

Expect new products to be announced based on Marvell technology all though 2010 and 2011 (and likely well beyond).

While competition is intense and there are many pitfalls, it looks to me like Marvell is going to become the very center of the semiconductor chip industry during this decade. Of course others have already entered the SoC business, and stand-alone chips will continue to be manufactured for equipment with volumes insufficient to justify an SoC design. I'm not saying the engineers at Intel, AMD, NVIDIA, Broadcom, Microchip, etc. are not very good, and all these companies have plenty of financial ability to compete however they like. But Marvell seems to have found how to

I have owned Marvell stock since January 2005.

For detailed results from Marvell's latest reported quarter, see my

Marvell Technology (MRVL) Q4 2010 analyst conference summary

See also www.marvel.com

Friday, August 28, 2009

Marvell Technology (MRVL) Under the Hood

About half of Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) revenue comes from its disk drive segment. It does not make hard drives; it makes the chips that enable the drives read and write data and communicate with the rest of the computer. This was Marvell's first business and it now dominates that market.

Like most technology companies, Marvell had a rocky last half of 2008 and first half of 2009. Even after a 23% sequential revenue increase in its latest quarter (which ended August 2, 2009; second quarter fiscal 2009) to $640.6 million, its revenue was down 24% from the year-earlier quarter. On the other hand, Q2 2008 had been a blockbuster quarter, with Marvell proving that its investments in new technologies could pay off.

While Marvell may yet expand its market share in the hard disk market, and that market may expand as nations like India and China continue to expand their technology sectors, to understand (or at least guess at) Marvell's future revenue, profits, and stock value you must look at the other 50% of the company. This revenue already was approximately $320 million in the latest quarter, yet many of its products are just beginning to produce revenue or are still in development.

The networking end market accounted for about 20% of revenue in the most recent quarter. This segment includes the chips that go into network switches and routers. This is a very big market, and highly competitive, but Marvell has plenty of room to grow its market share.

Mobile and wireless networking is also an important end market. Here the combined analog and digitial expertise of Marvell, which are now integrated onto single chips, comes into play. One new type of product using Marvell chips takes a 3G signal usually used for cell phones and broadcasts Wi-Fi for local wireless internet connectivity.

Marvell also makes chips to control printers. According to HP printer sales have not been so great this last year, so expect this segment to rebound when people's legacy printers start dying.

Most fascinating are Marvell's application and communication processors (based on Kirkwood and Discovery Innovation). These are designed for the type of high performance users now expect from mobile computing devices and use very low amounts of power. More important, Marvell is able to put these processors on a single chip with one or more of its other technologies. It already has chips that combine Bluetooth and Wi-Fi capabilities. Rather than just sell discrete chips, it works with customers to design whole systems-on-a-chip. Other companies do this, but Marvell is the leader in the field.

Some of this last year's profits have been made by cost-cutting, particularly in Research and Development. But the key to profitability has been the model of integrating functions on a chip for customers particular products. To paraphrase management: We will continue to have above-industry margins as long as we are able to build products that our competitors cannot match.

Marvell has video processing capabilities. It says it has many design wins, but does not announce anything until its customers make their own announcements. You can imagine what might be coming out in 2010: devices with a digital processor, video processor, and either wireless or wired communications capabilities all on a single chip. Which will lower costs for consumers, driving unit sales, while allowing both the OEM and Marvell to maintain high margins.

The usual risks and uncertainties apply in the highly competitive technology field.

See also my August 27, 2009 Marvell analyst conference summary.

And keep diversified!

Marvell site

Openicon Marvell main page

Friday, May 30, 2008

Marvell Reality Tops Goldman Downgrade

Earlier this week an analyst at Goldman Sachs downgraded Marvell Technologies (MRVL). The stock price dropped about 3%.

Yesterday Marvell announced its results for the quarter that ended May 3, 2008. At the analyst conference (See my summary) Marvell executives appeared very confident and had no trouble explaining why they were doing so well and expect to do well going forward. Today a bunch of firms upgraded Marvell and its stock jumped to over $17 per share.

All of this was reasonably foreseeable, as I can prove by directing you to my past articles at my main Marvell Technologies page.

Of course, reality sometimes turns the best analysis about the future wrong. Marvell has all the risks associated with the semiconductor industry.

Rather than re-analyse Marvell when my prior analysis is holding up pretty well, let's look at that Goldman Sachs downgrade. Maybe the guy was just wrong. Several analysts seemed to have bought into the idea that Marvell's position as the market share leader in the hard-drive controller chip industry is threatened by competitors. But it seems the competition is literally blowing hot air; their chips produce three times the heat as Marvell's, so only fools use them.

Sometimes a firm has advanced news of an event with market impact. Simple guys would just buy or sell on the news. But smart guys with a lot of money and political protection can issue an upgrade or downgrade, then buy or sell the stock at a better price and make even larger profits on the advanced information.

Don't think it has never happened, or won't happen again. In any case it is nice to see people who think upgrades and downgrades mean automatic profits get slaughtered once in a while.

Best to do your own analysis. And stay diversified!

See also www.marvell.com

Friday, August 24, 2007

Marvell's Huge Research and Development Budget

Marvell (MRVL) reported fiscal Q2 2008 earnings yesterday (August 23, 2007) with a GAAP loss of X or x per share. The stock lost 10% of its value in trading today. I believe some traders were hoping for a short-term pop because of rumors that a hedge fund had taken a position and that Marvell produced one part for Apple's iPhone cell phone. They overlooked the elephant in the room: Marvell's R&D (research and development) spending for the quarter. In fact the short-term sell-side analysts probably see the R&D budget as a negative. Here I'll focus on the future and the R&D expenses. For more on the past, see my notes on the Marvell analyst conference.

Marvell spent an astonishing $236 million on R&D in the quarter. Its revenues for the quarter were $657 million. So R&D was 36% of its budget. Compare that with, say Intel, which spent 30% of its revenues on R&D last quarter; or a more direct competitor, Linear Technology, which spent $47 million on R&D, or 17.5% of revenue.

It looks to me like Marvell is girding for war. They are not going to try to become the world's sole supplier of semiconductor chips, but they are going after a lot of cutting-edge, high volume, high margin business.

Some results are already rolling in. In May management guided Q2 revenues to $645 million; instead they came in at $657. Part of the differential probably came from chips that went in iPhones, but you have to remember that Marvell is already a big company. In fact it has pretty well made its intention clear: it is going after the 3G high-end phone market, not just Apple's tiny fraction of it. Last year it bought Intel's communication processor business (which this year is resulting in $36 million per quarter non-cash write offs of amortization costs, which really skews GAAP EPS downward). It was already developing its own communications processors. It also has some of the best analog radio technology in the industry. What it is doing is combining all of these functions - digital signal processing, general digital processing, and cell radio signal transmission with Wi-Fi and bluetooth. That is a killer combo. It does not mean there is no competition, or that any cell phone maker is required to adopt it. But those who do not may find themselves, in a year or two, at a severe competitive disadvantage.

Most companies that have done so well in making chips for hard-drive storage would see taking on the entire cell phone semiconductor industry as challenge enough. But not Marvell. It is also going after some other big hunks of business.

One is video processors for large screen TVs. Again, Marvell came to this game late. Again, the already have a foot in the door with some advanced silicon that makes for better pictures. Again, they are planning to solve a bunch of unsolved problems and deliver a solution that will be irresistible to the TV makers.

In parallel with that they are working on the DVD/ HD-DVD end of things as well.

Oh, and not satisfied with mere dominance in the hard drive industry, they have sunk a bunch of effort into R&D to make even better drive chips; they are confident they can gain revenues in this area.

Then there are their advance in LAN technology. And power management. And printer technology. I'm probably missing something, but that seems to cover the basics.

After a year in which Marvell and many other semiconductor makers got hit by inventory adjustments, slowed demand growth, and pricing pressure, Marvell's intense pursuit of new markets may be bearing fruit. Management believes Q3 revenues may come in around $710 million, up $53 million sequentially from Q2. I'll be very impressed if that happens.

More important, if they are right about design wins they are getting this year leading to significant new revenues in calendar 2008, I can't wait to see what Marvell looks like a year from now.

As to pricing the stock, you'll just have to choose your theory. I don't believe in buying stocks with high PE ratios, and right now if you use the GAAP numbers the PE ratio of Marvell is infinite. If you use non-GAAP numbers, it is pretty high. On the other hand I understand the value of R&D. Another company, trying to please short term investors, could have simply cut back its R&D budget in Q2 and shown some very impressive results. But as a long-term investor I'd rather have the company with the bad short term results, especially when its R&D arm has a record of paying off, as Marvell's has.

Right now I already own as much Marvell stock as my portfolio model allows, so I won't be buying more anytime soon. Even holding it at this level involves risk: just because Marvell is spending money on R&D does not mean it can sell any resulting technology. But that is a risk I can live with.

Friday, May 25, 2007

Marvell: Hero or Zero?

Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) was a hero to its investors back between mid-2002 and late 2005, when it rose from under $5 per share to over $30. Those who bought in too late (including me) have been disappointed by its slump to near $15 per share. Is Marvell now a bargain, a hero merely stunned in battle, or is it wounded and heading for the trash bin of semiconductor history?

Marvell makes semiconductor chips and is noted for advanced chips integrating digital and analog functions. The chips go in switches, transceivers, power management, printer, and communications products. But above all they go into hard drive based data storage devices.

If you look at revenue on an annual basis you will see rapid growth from 2001 ($288 million) forward to 2005's $1670 million. In the latest quarter report, in the typically seasonally weak Q1 2008, revenues were $635 million, which puts Marvell at an annual run rate of $2.5 billion. What is not to like about that?

First of all, we can only guess what net profits, if any, Marvell has been pulling in. It is one of those stock-option accounting, can't tell you anything until it is done firms. Management did say that, yes, there was incorrect dating of options; the investigation is essentially complete; they hope to file restatements and late statements with the SEC as soon as possible.

The other big shoe that fell was in the data storage market. Western Digital and Toshiba each amount for over 10% of Marvell's revenue. Marvell's superior products now command about 65% of market share. Marvell's rapid growth, and rapid stock price appreciation, came from going from 0% to 65%. Going over 65% is not easy for two reasons: competing chip makers are doing everything they can to hold on, and the hard drive manufacturers want to have alternative sources available because competition keeps prices reasonable.

After that the biggest concern other than a recession or potential weakness in the overall semiconductor market is in the XScale/cellphone sector. In 2006 Marvell bought Intel's division that produced XScale microprocessors that are meant to be used in advanced (3G) cell phones and PDAs. As everyone knows the PDA market is basically over. Intel was losing money in the division and needed to focus on its battle with AMD. Marvell payed too much for this asset, I think, but its executives believe that by combining XScale with Marvell's analog expertise (never an Intel strong point), lowering manufacturing costs, and gaining market share, this division could be very profitable. It is possible, of course, but the competition for chips going into 3G cell phones is intense, with some formidable players like Motorola in the mix. Just getting this segment to break even will impress most analysts.

Much of Marvell's revenue growth these last 2 years has been by acquisitions, including the printer chip division, which Marvell reports is doing well. Storage growth is limited by growth of the storage market itself.

There are a couple of bright spots on the horizon, notably advanced video processing chips. But so far these are contributing insignificant revenues.

The real fear: when the veil comes off, when the restatement is made, earnings will suck due to costs associated with the XScale acquisition. These should be one time costs, but they will give a bad impression.

My take? Worth the risk at this price. Once the accounting disruption is in the rear-view mirror and the Intel acquisition is digested we'll see what Marvell is doing and where it is heading. Marvell has always been well-managed, so I think the earnings picture will be pretty healthy.

Would a U.S. recession matter to Marvell? Some, but it sells its chips into a global economy. With Germany and China booming, with India and Japan coming along, I don't see a global recession near-term.

Reminder: I own Marvell stock.

More information:

My Marvell page, with links to my summaries of analyst conferences
Marvell web site
openicon.com